of principles to new conditions. But orthodoxy or Judaism could not pause to deliberate, to legislate, to declare alterations in the law without endangering the law itself. Judaism thus acted as the preservative of Jewish national life, but in the process of preservation, much of it became dead in reality. As a defensive measure, orthodoxy could not be excelled, but as a means of progress, greater life, recognition of possibilities, learning from experience, it was utterly inadequate.
But it served and still serves its purpose. It kept down rebels with the threat of ostracism; it charged the rebel with weakening the national defenses. It maintained the solidarity of Jewry.
But since the era of emancipation, and the growth: of the democratic idea among nations, Jewish orthodoxy has had a hard fight to control its adherents in the face of the open door of freedom. Its walls have been razed by the spread of liberal ideas, not only among the gentiles, but also among its own members. The alien idea of religion as the expression of the relation of the individual to God has raised questions as to the truth or falsity of Jewish religious ideas. The retention of mediæval ideas in the synagogue on the ground of national defense has not appealed to those who are not susceptible to the national appeal. Orthodoxy has come face to face with the world religions, and it has been compelled to meet the demands for a statement as to what it is in the terms of these alien religions. Christianity has been refined to the extent of eliminating its Hebraic influences and as a religion, in that sense, Judaism must now explain itself. Science has penetrated and invalidated the myths the allegories, the metaphysical theology of all religions, and they have been forced to restate their positions. Orthodox Judaism, with its national bias, must maintain itself against destructive influences from without as well as from within.
In other words, orthodoxy must declare for nationalism or give up the right to maintain its mediæval fences. Where the
members of the Jewish race come under the influence of the Christian idea of individual religion, a national religion without a national center, that has not moved forward for centuries to become a national entity, cannot satisfy.
And orthodoxy cannot reform. The very basis of its existence in the goluth is the necessity of preserving the ancient traditions. Once it opens the door to innovation, in the midst of aliens, it invites its own death.
Orthodoxy therefore must have as its postulate the condition that all these traditions and customs, all these ceremonies and ideals, have been preserved against the day of the restoration of the Jewish people. Until the restoration, we must maintain intact our heritage of national hope, national trust, national worship, but when we are once resettled in our own soil, then the rebels may speak out, and we shall begin the inevitable struggle for the rejuvenation of our religion and life. Orthodoxy must be taken as a war measure. It is the policy of the military general, who must silence all criticism while his army is passing through the enemy's territory. In a time of peace, criticism and reform may be in order; but while the Jews are still in goluth, the reformer is the rebel, whose place is in the ranks, mute.
To make this point clearer: orthodoxy may for a time maintain the integrity of the Jewish people by silencing dissensions, but it represents a temporary and an untenable policy that cannot be enforced wherever democracy or religious tolerance have full sway. It cannot hold its army together unless it takes steps to move for the realization of those hopes that will make a state of war unnecessary. It gives a reason for the Jewish existence as a separate people with a national religion only if it admits and strives for the return of the Jews to their normal position as a nation. As a religion, minus Zionism, that is, it is bound to be a dogmatic enigma. But inspired by Zionism, it may receive the support and the