to give a positive statement of its beliefs, because it has never been able to establish a leading principle, and it has never found one principle to which a majority of reform rabbis will subscribe. In other words, representing the abasement of the Jewish people and expressing gratitude for the material comforts allowed them, reform Judaism finds it necessary to propitiate every local god, each according to his condition, and harmony is impossible because the local conditions are subject to variation, progress, and normal development, while the Jews, as echoes, cannot attempt to impress their individuality on the life they are trying to imitate or conciliate.
It is evident that under such conditions, it is impossible for reform Judaism to conserve and retain any of the principles of Jewish life, and that the future will surely witness more and more encroachments upon the integrity of Jewish ideals, and that the outcome of the reform movement is the complete abdication of Judaism; in other words, complete assimilation. By complete assimilation I mean, a final absorption of whatever there is in Jewish religion or Jewish life, which can be differentiated from the life and the religion of the majority of the population. Reform Judaism will not be able to withstand the pressure and will be compelled to abandon everything which Christianity will refuse to allow to hold. It will ever dance the tune its neighbors play.
There remains, then, Jewish Orthodoxy. When the Jewish nationality dispersed, the learned men, the patriots, established a spiritual nationality, transferring to the realm of spirit that principle upon which Jewish life was based, hoping that the regathering of the scattered elements might one day become possible, but, at the same time, while relegating the idea of a nationality to the inner life, the spiritual life, they presented to the Jewish people the laws which were actually to govern them in spite of the temporary absence of the nation. They made the law the fence which was to preserve the integrity of
Jewish life. They conceded certain compromises only when life itself was affected, but they always lived as men to whom the law of God was supreme: Orthodoxy, or the Jewish religion, thus became the fortress, the buttress of Jewish national life. They lived it as if Titus had not destroyed the Temple. They remained the same after the Romans had razed the ground, only, instead of an actual national center, they had a spiritual national center. The conqueror could not destroy them, could not eradicate Jewish life, no matter what he did to their persons, their property, for in their inner life, Rome and its cruel law based on the rights of property had no effect. They were the bearers of light, they were the chosen people. They suffered, but their suffering was the penalty God had inflicted upon them for their shortcomings; and they were to be everlastingly preserved in order that God's light should not disappear from among men.
Wherever they went, their inner life remained the same. There may have been variations, but in essence, they were the eternal Jews who never changed. While Christianity was struggling with heathen forces, and swallowing them in part or in whole, the Jews abided in their law. They witnessed the rise and fall of empires, but they abided and trusted in their God. Their way of life was God's commandment. The Lord was their shepherd and the heathen were the wolves who sought to rend them.
But orthodoxy did not preserve a free growing Jewish life. What we know as orthodoxy has, by force of circumstances, retained whatever obsolete ideas and customs it has, because, being always on the defensive, none could with authority modify or remove what experience had actually proved to be useless and harmful. A law cannot remain stationary. In the development of any jurisprudence, the elements of circumstance and need compel a modification or enlargement of principles. The whole structure of the English common law is the result of adjustment
