might nor by power, but by my spirit." The Turkish Revolution, Achad-Haam goes on to say, is of signal importance to us Zionists, not because of the many possibilities it has opened for practical work in Palestine, but for the valuable lesson it contains, a fact which has been entirely overlooked by many. For nearly thirty years we have now been active in Palestine and how amazingly insignificant are the results of our labors. We have been building castles in the air; we have deceived ourselves in thinking that practical work in Palestine will win for our cause the hearts of the people and make them staunch supporters of our movement. The bulk of the people has remained indifferent to our cause and the recent developments in Turkey fully confirm this deplorable fact. The good tidings of the opening of endless possibilities in Palestine should have spread like an electrical current setting every hand in motion and stimulating every one to intense activity. But what do we actually see? The same lack of interest, the same apathy and the same inactivity as before, except that a new subject has been added for discussion to fill up the emptiness and hollowness of our party organs and programmes of society meetings.
Ask the young Turks and they will tell you the cause of this indifference. Had we devoted all our energies during these thirty years to educate the people, to awaken their national consciousness, to strengthen the ties that unite them with our glorious past and with the land of our fathers, had we done all this, we would perhaps have had to-day a large army of devoted and enthusiastic workers with deep national feelings who, when an opportune moment arrives, would form excellent material for the upbuilding of a Jewish future in Palestine. "Not by might nor by power, but by spirit" was our motto since the time of Zerubbabel and this must remain our guiding principle for the future if we really desire to build up a powerful national movement.
Achad-Haam is not content with merely
pointing out unpardonable errors in the past in not accepting the young Turk methods as our spiritual guidance, but he also tells us with great certainty that the favorable conditions created in Turkey will attract non-Jewish capital to Palestine in large quantities and that the economical and social development of the land will for a long time remain in the hands of others. But there is nothing to prevent us from taking possession of the land in an educational and cultural way. A number of elementary and secondary schools, universities and academies for art and science, would not only increase our spiritual influence in Palestine but would also gradually (strengthen our economic and social position in the land. That we possess the moral and material forces necessary for such a spiritual conquest, Achad-Haam is firmly convinced. He assures us that if there still flickers a spark of national feeling in the hearts of our people under the ashes of the Goluth, it could be converted into a glowing flame through intense spiritual activity, but not through petty enterprises in the form of practical work in Palestine.
There is nothing in the article that sounds new to those familiar more or less with the views of Achad-Haam, yet one can hardly peruse its contents without being impressed with its inappropriateness and forced logic. To assert now, in the face of hopeful outlooks in Palestine, that the economic and social developments of the land will for a long time remain in the hands of others, is equivalent to stating indefinitely that the land will remain forever in the hands of others and we have no hope whatever of acquiring Palestine. Justly does the old Zionist vereran, M. L. Lilienblum, remark in his reply to Achad-Haam that should we now fail to avail ourselves of the favorable conditions, our chances will be greatly impaired, if not entirely lost. To advocate the adoption of a new policy in propagating the Zionist ideal, to wait till through educational work there will come a complete and radical change in
