Jewish immigration into America has reached a point, where our philanthropists, those who are constantly denouncing Zionism, are compelled to abandon the task of solving the Jewish problem by dispersion, and to admit the premises of the restrictionists. The Jews followng a sociological law, will not scatter. What follows? Mr. Schiff may not be a restrictionist, but the thing he sees before him to do for the relief of Jewish congestion is practically the program of the restrictionists. The restrictionists object to the presence of numerous Jews in any one locality for anti-Semitic reasons; Mr. Schiff objects to such congestion on the ground that the burden of releiving the consequences of congestion is too heavy for the Jewish community here.
America is now in the same position England was in 1902, when its Alien Commission sat. At that time, there were Jews who advocated the dispersion of the Jews from London, thus practically admitting that congestion, aside from its ordinary evils, had a special coloring when that congestion was Jewish. When Herzl testified before that commission, he said:
"That Jews themselves should be devising means for excluding their own people from whole districts, is monstrous. In principle they are pursuing the same policy as those who favor a restriction of alien immigration. ...If to-day there is an evil in one spot, the plan being successful, to-morrow the evil would be in many spots."
Mr. Schiff is not alone in the holding of the views quoted above. In 1902 the leading Jews in the United States informed their English brethren that they could not receive and distribute any more Jewish immigrants. The same complaint is heard from the heads of charitable and philanthropic institutions. It is generally heard most loudly from these who do not have to similulate defenders of the anti-Zionist policy. All these admissions are the confession of the bankruptcy of American Jewish philanthropy.
In view of these facts, the following quo-
tation from Herzl’s Jewish State is pertinent:
The Jewish question exists wherever.Jews live in perceptible numbers. Whereit does not exists, it is carried by Jews inthe course of their migrations. We naturally move to those places where we arenot persecuted, and there our presencecreates persecution. This is the case inevery country, and will remain so even inthose highly civilized countries, France itself being no exception, until the Jewishquestion finds a solution on a politicalbasis."
The United States government has adopted the policy of consulting the primary interests of this country, and the immigration of any nationality must be weighed in the balance of those interests. It is bound to maintain that policy as long as the protective tariff is maintained. The protection of capital, without the protection of labor from foreign competition, will not long be endured by the laboring classes. All this is aside from the prejudices against the Jews, which increase with their numbers.
Our philanthropic leaders have no such clear-cut policy. They have two policies. When appearing for aliens held up by Mr. Williams, they plead for the admission of every able-bodied Jew. When speaking to Jews, they are alarmed over congestion, the drain upon charitable institutions, and even favor the closing of the port of New York.
The unfortunate plight of our brethren who land at Ellis Island renews the feelof anguish we Zionists feel when the direct and brutal consequences of the Golus life are brought home to us. We sympathize with our philanthropists who are torn between their natural racial sympathies and their own self-interest. At the same time we call upon all Jews to heed the admonitions of Zionists: Prepare for the salvation of the Jewish nation; and do not remain deaf to the call of that movement, which aims to prevent the recurrence of the sad spectacles now to be seen every day at Ellis Island.
