The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 2 · August 1909
50printed page
scan 2 of 52
50
THE MACCABAEAN

that Zionism would jeoparidze the position of the Turkish Jews.

Dr. Riza Tekfik, another deputy, who is not a Jew, spoke more frankly and with an evident sympathy for the Jewish interests, than did the Jewish deputies. He said:

"I know that opinions are divided as to Zionism. I, too, have formed my opinions on the matter, because I am indebted for my primary education to the Jews; and I have always been grateful to them on that account. Believe me, I am one of their best friends among the Turks; and I have always endeavored to secure for the Jews the conditions of a happy life. Now, as I understand Zionism, it is an echo of the inhumanity and anomalous conditions to which the Jewish race has been subjected. The Jews, beng the most aristocratic people of antiquity, were always maltreated and lost their political position. This aroused in the hearts of the people a desire to become a nation themselves. Always regarded as a people sans patrie, they experienced a strong desire to have a land of their own somewhere. Turkey having come to be 'the sick man of Europe,' the Jews believe that his impending disssolution would offer them the chance of becoming centralized in Palestine. Now, this form of Zionism is quite well known in Turkey, and it constitutes a great danger for the Jews. You must understand that the fear of all the Ottoman Turks is the separatist peril and the disintegration of the Empire. We are a composite people; and we have not yet become amalgamated so as to evolve a definite type of Ottoman. If the young Israelites and the idealists among them pursue this deal of Zionism they will create in Turkey a Jewish question; and the consequences will be just the reverse of what they want.

"We have in Turkey many good lands, and, above all, Mesopotamia, which is twelve times better than Palestine. We need money and workers in these lands. Let the Jewish immigrants take in hand the development of these territories. They can go to Palestine, too, if they choose.

But they must not forget that Jerusalem is the sacred city of all nations. If Turkey thought of giving Jerusalem to the Jews, the rest of the world would not allow it. Let the Jews spread themselves over the Turkish Empire and not concentrate in one portion of it. Let them make the country their fatherland, becoming Ottoman subjects, and dismissing from their minds the idea of Jewish autonomy. In this way the Jews can pursue Zionism without speaking of it. The proper aim of Zionism is the happiness and welfare of the majority of the Jewish nation, but there is a kind of Zionism which may defeat that object and achieve the opposite. Many young Jews do not think of this. The subject must be looked at from two points of view. This is the point I would impress on my Jewish friends.."

These interviews have evoked the usual sensational alarms in the Yiddish press but in our opinion, Zionists need not lose courage on that account. The fact is, that whatever legal advantages have been gained, are in no way jeopardized by the obiter dicta of Turkish deputies travelling in Europe. Turkey at the present time is a constitutional monarchy. What it has to say it says through its Ministry and its Parliament.

As an indication of Turkish public opinion, however, these interviews are invaluable. They are guides, or should be guides in the cultivation of a proper understanding of the utility of sensible diplomacy on the part of Zionist leaders. There isn't a Zionist, we believe, who ever dreamed of pressing the question of autonomy into the field of immediate operations. A political movement presses a question only when life itself calls forth the issue, Zionism does not insist on the recognition of theoretical questions. It is not concerned with: the acceptance of its entire program; it presents practical work, and with the practical work proposed by the movement, nothing that has been said by Turkish deputies is in disagreement. The movement has adopted as itsı policy the instructions to every immigrant to become a Turkish citi-