The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 2 · August 1909
72printed page
scan 24 of 52
72
THE MACCABARAN

veloped retain the idea that they are always the pioneers of the Jewish people. Nor could it well be otherwise where the life struggle becomes hard and individual and is not arrested by such forces as the exercise of governmental functions, etc.

At the convention there was no opportunity to discuss this in detail. What we attempted to do was to translate this idea into action. That in order that every effort at colonization shall not become so confused with Zionism as to be regarded as the whole objective of our cause, all such efforts shall operate through the National Fund. It would be nonsense for us to say that individuals shall not or may not do this or that, but we believe that the moment an individual desires for some action of his the sanction, commendation or support of our movement then our movement must safeguard the national interest envolved in such an undertaking. There is nothing strange in this. If the builder of a hotel desires to make his establishment part of a city's pride to be boosted in its official boosts, the well-ordered city protects its interest and name by demanding that the hotel shall rise to a certain standard in building, rooms, appointments and what not.

Those who struggled for this were not out to catch votes. They demanded a roll-call because they felt that every delegate should have one moment's reflection on this before voting, and the result

showed that nearly one-half the delegates understood this clearly.

The third part of the convention struggle merely recovered the first and secondwith a new added confusion due to thesudden introduction of a new Synthesisof the movement. Dr Magnes soughtto achieve a harmony of sound whereasif there be a synthesis every word mustbe weighed and its extremes of meaningthought out. We were spellbound by theorator, but when the oration itself wascondensed into five resolutions we werenot persuaded that they were relevant,good or expressive of the needs of thehour. The Committee on Resolutionsthought likewise and so the convention inthe end adopting its forms agreed withthose who started the `struggle.

When a ship is about to enter a strange harbor, the captain takes soundings every few minutes. The lead and line are his guides over the shoals, and the more often he uses them the less his danger of striking against a sunken shoal. This is what the convention by resolution did. If our leaders refuse to guide the fleet, if they cannot find the passage to a safe anchorage, then it will be proper to criticise them freely, but whilst we cannot consult our captain let us continue carefully to sound those new depths. No eternity of patience is involved in this, and at least we prevent the stranding of our vessel.