been made to overhaul the scheme of organization. During the last four years all attempts to do this have failed, because with an increasing number of issues presented to it, the convention could digest no single one—passed some in particular when it was tired and consigned the rest to the scrap heap of executive reference.
Now, if Zionists will examine the work of their own society they will find the same confusion prevailing. No sooner shall a man mention Jewish Colonial Trust than another will mention the relative merits of the Olive Tree and Bezalel Funds, and in the end a given dollar is merely split up into ten dimes.
The first part of the struggle at the convention, which the Exxecutive itself favored, on paper, but on which the administration remained silent, was to effect a re-concentration of effort upon the primary needs of the movement. The Actions Committee has too willingly enfolded every plan that may benefit the Jewish people; the Federation has obeyed too loyally in the same direction, and has added minor issues of its own, to leave the movement free to operate. After years of patience "the stars in their courses are fighting for Israel." Turkey is opening its doors. It is perfectly natural that thousands should be willing to rush in, that hundreds should evolve new plans. It seemed to a few of us that this was just a moment when we should endeavor to clear the decks of the good ship Zionism and put her into fighting trim. The opposition, on the contrary, were willing that every one should employ his own patent gun, load it and fire it just as he saw fit. That the struggle raged around Mr. Goldman's $1,000,000 colonization plan was but merely incidental at the outset, because some of us thought there was too much variety of action even without that. It became more serious when through this confusion of method we were simply led into a confusion of thought.
Now, when a movement become confused in thought, it becomes confused in
purpose. Many aims make aimlessness—witness the aimlessness of every Jewish movement in existence from the Alliance Israelite Universelle onward to the very latest creation. The mental confusion at the convention brought forth the sentence “We want every Jew to have his own plot of land in Eretz Israel.” That does not represent Zionism any more than does the Industrial Removal office’s appeal to Jews to settle on farms and in small towns. Not only is it not Zionism, but it is a sentiment dangerous to Zionism. Just about 20 years ago Rabbi Ch. Maccoby raised a similar cry in London, won thousands around him and naturally failing of his purpose doomed the then Chovevi Zion to its lingering death.
So there was pressed upon us part of an old fight—an important one. We we'e accused of opposing "practical" w rk. The practical is merely so because it lies easily to hand, to some extent, because it can afford to forget three failures in the glow of one partial success. The "practical" leaders will, however, not discuss whether or not it is practical to the main issue—the main issue being that Zionism seeks to create a national centre for the Jews, in Palestine. The conditions are peculiar, both as applied to the people and to the land. Palestine is not a wild new chaos into which people can pour themselves and then create a new nationality for themselves. The Jews are not the people who can use the power of concentration as to the manor born. We exhibit our traits and characteristics, not our strength. In brief, there is ahead of individual colonization in Palestine the risk of creating a great community of Palestinians of the Jewish persuasion who whilst smugly comfortable will have accomplished nothing to lift the weight of the golus, in other words will contribute nothing but their philanthropy to the solution of the Jewish Question. If you doubt this, ask what efforts the Palestinian Jews—those brought there by colonization—are making to bring Jews into Palestine? Only those who go there with national consciousness intensely de-
