quered races. How much more anxious would Jews be to lose themselves in the rest of the world, since they everywhere hold the position of a conquered race, if it were true that all that creates fellow feeling among us were merely blood-relationship. Persecution and ostracism, social and political, would in that case make our desire to assimilate even the keener.
As a matter of fact, however, if persecution and ostracism have been known to have any effect it has been that calling forth of a greater amount of resistance to assimilation. Persecution has always challenged something in the Jew which can not be merely blood relationship. It has stung him into a self-dignity and self-appreciation unknown before and that fellow feeling which would lies dormant in many quarters has been known to spring into new life.
While I do not regard either religion or race as the sole foundation for this Jewish fellow feeling, I do not wish to be understood as saying that they had nothing to do with building up that fellow feeling. On the contrary, I am the first to pronounce that in the past, religion was the strongest impetus towards such fellow feeling, and that in the present, it is the memory of this religious ancestral experience which the most freethinking and the most pietistic Jews have in common, that goes a great way towards building up and preserving that fellow feeling. The same may be said of our having a common blood relationship, viz: that it is a very important element in making all Jews feel associated. But what I contend is that neither of these alone nor together are sufficient to account for all of the fellow feeling which is so real and so perceptible a factor in Jewish life. That wherein religion and racial ties are even more inadequate to account for this Jewish fellow feeling is when the latter assumes not merely the form of a passive feeling which exists in a vague way, and which is exercised only as pain or pleasure in the knowledge of good or evil which befalls our fellow Jews, but when it assumes a forward, active and aggressive movement as in Zionism;
when it speaks out loud and strong in assertion of its own self and of its rights, when it is not satisfied with merely being tolerated but demands an enlarged field for activity; when this same fellow being refuses to remain in vague aspiration but means to become organized power, when it wishes to see itself realized not only in the domain of the spiritual but also in the domain of active, practical, useful and beautiful life—when the Jewish fellow-feeling assumes these forms, a common past experience, or even blood relationship, are far from accounting for it. The one concept which alone can account for these wonderful manifestations of Jewish fellow-feeling is Nationality, and for that reason the Jews form not only a religion, not only a race, but a nation. To deny nationality to the Jewish community, you have to deny that the Jewish fellow-feeling assumes the different forms that have been named. Why it shows itself in these various ways and not merely in the vague and recusant manner that many Jews would want it, is neither for you nor for me to say. He who governs the destinies of nations wants it so, and it is for us to make the best of it we can. Jewish Nationality is not a fact to be proved or disproved; it is simply a fact to be dealt with by each Jew and by each according to his best lights.
Now that we recognize the bond of nationality in Jewish life, the various efforts to intensify Jewish life are not merely efforts to change or improve the condition of certain individuals, but represent the will of a whole nation to live. In all these efforts to enable the Jew to remain a Jew and develop his life and power as a Jew, there underlies the same mystic and unaccountable force which exists in every living thing, viz., the will to live. Whenever Jewish Congregations or Jewish Universities, or Jewish Institutions are organized, whenever attempts are made at the cultivation of the riebrew language, the study of Jewish Literature and History, and most of all in the reawakened longing for Palestine, we have the expression of the Jewish national will to live. But as the will to live in an individual may show
