The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 2 · August 1909
60printed page
scan 12 of 52
60
THE MACCABAEAN

let us say on the basis of religion pure and simple, or racial ties, they still would constitute a nation.

Now, there is no doubt in any one's mind that those who call themselves Jews, experience a certain amount of fellow feeling. No matter how distant apart there is some note to which every Jewish heart will respond. If one were able to weigh and measure the various amounts of fellow feeling that exists among the different members of any other social group or nation he would find that it is nowhere as strong as it is among those who call themselves Jews. The most indifferent Jew will take pride in the achievements or lower his head in the disgrace of a fellow Jew. As an illustration of the latter, we have had the Dreyfus case, and not only is this fellow feeling experienced by Jews, but objectified into a formidable fact with powerful and dangerous instrumentalities by the Jew haters. No matter how disorganized we are, no matter how independently of each other we may declare ourselves as acting, the body of Jew haters is sure to accuse us of world wide confederacies and conspiracies. This fellow feeling is a real and unmistakable fact.

Now, on what is this fellow feeling based? The answer which Reform Judaism gives is that it is based on religion. Jews feel themselves kin, related, because they profess a certain religion which is not the same as the religion of their fellow citizens. If that were the case the fellow feeling which exists among the Jews would arise from their having one form of religion, and hence the Jews would make up primarily a religious community. But one must indeed wear a pair of magic spectacles which lower all hills and raise all valleys, which straighten all crooked lines and smoothen all roughness for the one that wears them, to see in all Jews but one form of religion. If rabid agnosticism which borders on atheism, rational explanation of the supernatural, belief in the infallability of every iota of the written and the oral law, superstitions which reckon with evil spirits on every step in human life, if all these are one form of religion

then we Jews have one religion, indeed. If the Apostle of the West, who has banished the Torah from the Synagogue and the light of the East who has surreptitiously smuggled in the Sunday Sabbath for his followers, together with the forty rabbis of Russia who would not admit a great Rabbi like Reines into their council, have one form of religion, then that ends the matter, and we Jews are nothing but a religious community. But I am sure that our better judgments will from a purely religious point of view more easily group Emil Hirsch with Bob Ingersoll and the reactionary rabbis of Russia with the Jesuits. What remains then of the basis of religion as something upon which the real intense Jewish fellow feeling is to be established?

Let us now see what truth there is in another answer which has been much in vogue of late. It is said that our Jewish fellow feeling is to be traced to our common ancestry. It is merely a matter of blood relationship. I must confess that this way of accounting for our fellow feeling is a far more plausible one than the one of religion. It at least is true that we are descended from one stock. Even if other races of our family stocks were grafted into the Jewish, they have all by this time been thoroughly Judaized through intermarriage with the genuine Jewish stock. But if the only ground of Jewish unity were blood kinship, the great body of Jews would not feel so strongly on the matter of being absorbed by other races and nationalities. The opposition to assimilation is manifest among all classes of believing or non-believing Jews, whereas no race as a race has ever been known to oppose assimilation. If those of one race did oppose it, it was usually due to some other bond, e.g., religious or social ,they wanted to see maintained. As far as races pure and simple are concerned they have always shown a tendency to mingle with other . races, and even nature seems to favor their intermixture. All great European nations are conglomerates of various races. Even conquering races have been known to intermingle with con-