The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 1 · July 1909
42printed page
scan 42 of 60

a vote of 66 to 51. The vote on the substitute was decided by a roll call.

Resolution No. 4 to the Congress, reading as follows, was put:

"That we consider it inadvisable for the coming Congress to alter the wording or meaning of the so-called Basle Program; but if the present Turkish situation demands a special expression of opinion, that the Congress adopt a resolution formulating our attitude and intentions with regard to the furtherance of the work of the movement in Palestine."

Magnes moved the tabling of the resolution, and the adoption of other resolutions that would clarify the Zionist situation. He offered the following as a substitute:

“The twelfth annual convention of the Federation of American Zionists places itself on record as ’ollows:

"We express our joy at the victory of the forces of freedom in the Ottoman Empire and in the granting of a constitution under which all nationalities of the Empire are guaranteed national freedom in a united Empire.

"We send our brotherly greetings in particular to our fellow Jews of the Constitutional army and to all others who have struggled for constitutional freedom and we hail with satisfaction their welcome by their Ottoman comrades as free Ottoman citizens of a free Jewish nationality.

“We reaffirm our determination to create a Jewish national center in Palestinefor the Jewish people and in pursuit ofthis aim we recognize the principle of theintegrity of the Ottoman Empire.

“We rejoice at the necessity that compels the Ito to direct its attention to a territory within the Turkish Empire, and we would point out to that organization the advantages of Palestine as a center of national life for the Jewish people, a land which is fruitful and contains great possibilities of development, and which can give support to 10,000,000 of our people, a land which is ours by historical right. We therefore call upon all Jewish organizations and upon all Jews to join the Zionist organization in our work on behalf of the settlement of Palestine by Jews.

“We reaffirm our determination to preserve and to develop our Jewish nationality in the Golus, in so far as that is possible.

Magnes said that the time had arrived for the reformulation of the Zionist policy; the Zionists should not be slow to recognize the new conditions.

There was a great deal of uncertainty as to the Zionist policy and an effort ought to be made by the convention to clarify the situation. It must be recognized that Chovevi Zionism was good in its time, and Herzlian Zionism was good for the time it existed. But we are facing a new era in Turkey. He confessed that since the Turkish revolution he was inclined to consider himself a Chovev Zion. Political Zionism had been useful. Without it the attention of the Jewish people would not have been turned to Palestine, as it is to-day. It had been the greatest Jewish movement of the diaspora. But we must reckon with a changed situation. What does national and autonomous basis mean? Is not the settlement of Jews in Palestine under a free government sufficient to cover the requirements in that respect? He asked the convention to declare that it wishes that the Ottoman Empire be preserved in its integrity; it should declare that the Zionist movement is not a separatist movement. It is the duty of Zionists to establish a synthesis of Chovevi Zionism and Herzlian Zionism. He was in accord with the principle that the Zionist organization should not become responsible for individual enterprises; but the convention should say something to the world on a number of pressing questions. He advocated the adoption of a resolution of congratulations to the Ito organization for the necessity that compels it to direct its attention to the free Ottoman Empire, but to say to the Ito organization that we regarded the Mesopotamia scheme, if it be intended as a Jewish national movement, as impractical and as forgetful of the importance of Palestine in the history and development of Judaism, for Palestine can give sustenance to 10,000,000 Jews, and every spot of it is capable of cultivation. The Zionist