The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 1 · July 1909
41printed page
scan 41 of 60
THE MACCABAEAN

Resolution No. 3, on the Congress, was then presented. The resolution read as follows :

"That the Actions Comite be moderate in its efforts to make the Zionist organization responsible for a number of Palestinian enterprises that are not specifically national in their scope, and that it devote itself to the upbuilding of the National Fund, of the capital of the Jewish Colonial Trust, and to those investigations of Palestine that are essential to a large national occupation of the land."

Cowen presented a substitute motion, signed by Kazmann, Richards, Cowen, Lipsky, Joseph, de Haas and others. The substitute, which was the subject of the discussion that followed, read thus:

"Whereas, the fundamental principle of Zionism as expressed in the Basle program is the concentration of Jews in Palestine on a national and autonomous basis.

"And, whereas, in order to realize this end, the movement created the Jewish Colonial Trust and the National Fund,

"Be it resolved, that the Actions Comite concentrate its efforts and devote itself to the upbuilding of the National Fund, of the capital of the Jewish Colonial Trust, and to those investigations of Palestine as are essential to a large national occupation of the land; and that neither the Actions Comite nor any subsidiary committee thereof make the Zionist organization responsible for any Palestinian enterprise not specifically national in its scope."

By order of the President, the delegates were asked to speak on the substitute alternately, one for it, the other against it.

The debate was opened by Kazmann, who pointed out the necessity for having the one national organization of the Jewish people firm in its own convictions, strong in its resistance to any opportunistic advantages, and consciously devoted to the high ideal it had set before itself. Wortsmann spoke against the substitute, saying that the Zionists must take advantage of present circumstances and could not afford to hinder the colonization of Palestine by adhering to a formula, which the times had made ineffective and even harmful.

Lipsky, in an explanation of the substitute, said that the Zionist organization must resist every temptation to dissipate its strength, and must remain steadfast as the representative of the national ideal. Others may do Zionist work, Zionists as individuals are urged to take up the work, but the organization itself should tenaciously uphold only those institutions that tend to strengthen the Jewish nationality as such. The National Fund, he said, is the guarantee against the diversion or dissipation of the National ideal, and while it is strong, and the Jewish Colonial Trust is active, the National ideal will be enabled to stand any setbacks and tide over any of the failures of the individual Jews, who, inspired by Zionist ideals, take up the work of settling Palestine.

Eichler said that he did not believe in giving much attention to the text of a platform. The object of Zionism was to obtain Palestine, and to do that, the land must be settled by Jews. Cowen retorted that the Zionist organization can be responsible for ideals only, it cannot become responsible for men. Zionists must uphold this ideal, prevent its pollution, resist every effort to reduce its spiritual and moral and national value. De Haas said that Zionism seeks to create a Jewish state in Palestine, it does not aim at getting individuals into Zion, who will have to struggle for their own individual existence and then may forget all about the nation. There can be a Palestine settled with Jews, which will not be the home of the Jewish nation. The Zionist organization, he said, stands for the national ideal, the national self-consciousness. Fishlowitz also spoke, favoring immediate practical work in Palestine without hindrance.

Bublick moved the previous question. Richards objected, on the ground that the list of speakers had not been exhausted. The previous motion was carried.

A vote was taken on the substitute. Cowen's motion was lost by a vote of 54 to 70.

The original motion was then put. The original motion, "That the Actions Committee be moderate, etc.," was adopted by