The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 1 · July 1909
32printed page
scan 32 of 60
22
THE MACCABAEAN

mitting it to be used by an individual for personal purposes, that I recommended to the Executive Committee that the Charter of the society be revoked. This was done, but unfortunately, my advice that the facts be sent to the officers of the Knights of Zion was not followed; and the society` was recognized at the last. convention of that organization, and its leader, Moses Winthrop, was one of the orators of that event. The other cases I have in mind are those of societies now defunct, which had considerable money in their treasuries at the time of their dissolution, which has not yet been turned over to the various funds of` the movement, and which, apparently, never will be. One society in Kansas had about $400 in its treasury, which it turned over to a synagogue, ostensibly as a loan; but the loan is one that can probably never be collected. I also found societies which had failed to turn in their shekel receipts, were still selling Shekolim out of the 1907 books. The only way in which this evil can be remedied is to require reports from the societies at frequent intervals, and even to bond the treasurers. A form of procedure for meetings should be drafted, which could be so arranged as to serve as a guide `to the societies, and at the same time a guide to the Federation in indicating and requiring certain regular correspondence with the societies.

The treasurer's report shows the financial outcome of the tour. But thoughfigures are said to be truthful, they arenot descriptive. It would appear, for instance, that about one-fifth of theamounts raised, are by way of annual contributions. But as a matter of fact, ifthe same cities were revisited, the amountof annual contributions would easily benot less than 60 to 70 per cent. Manybusiness men are averse to pledging themselves for continual payments, but myexperience has been in most cities revisited, that they will give whenever personally called upon. Thus, for instance,in San Antonio, in Houston and in Jacksonville, those who contributed last year,contributed again this year, and the totals

were, increased at an average of 150 per cent. And in such cities where the total was not increased, contributions were obtained for a second time by a personal call, although bills had not been honored. It must be evident from this experience, that one visit to a city will not suffice. They must be gone to over and over again, until the people come to regard their contributions to the Zionists as an obligation which must be met.

The question will naturally arise, whythe sum raised was not larger in spiteof the amount of propaganda and agitation that was conducted. To be sure, thefault may be with your representative,who has no desire to "save his face" ormake excuses. But the facts are these:Local conditions are a very importantcontrolling factor. Some of these I havealready indicated. But others, and evenmore important, are entirely beyond ourcontrol. For instance, if the cotton-cropis small, a town like Shreveport, La.,is financially paralyzed, and though thewillingness to give may be there the ability is not. In Texas, in Florida, in Kentucky and other states, the unsettlementof business due to the enactment, orthreatened enactment of a prohibition law,causes a money stringency. In some sections, the financial depression of last yearis still felt keenly: Louisville, Ky., Norfolk, Va., are instances. And so it goes:Whatever affects, or threatens to affect,business, affects the Jewish communities,and while philanthropic institutions, whichhave been in the field for some time, aresufferers to a lesser degree, the Zionistmovement, which does not and will notappeal to the primitive emotion of pity,and is the newest in the money-solicitingfield, is made to feel it most. Then, again,it must be borne in mind that the Jewsoutside of New York are the most heavily taxed of all peoples. A week doesnot pass by without a visit from a fieldagent of some philanthropic institution oranother. Those who give to one, generally give to most; and these are thepeople who must be appealed to also bythe Zionist movement. It has become a