The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 1 · July 1909
29printed page
scan 29 of 60
Facsimile · scan 29 of 60
Scan of p. 29
Text · transcribed from the scan

Charleston, 3 meetings, attendance 650.

A short tour was made up,after Passover as follows:

Virginia : Norfolk, 1 meeting, attendance350; Newport News, 1 meeting, attendance 200; Portsmouth, 1 meeting, attendance 150. Maryland : Baltimore, 2 meetings, attendance 200. District of Columbia,Washington, no meetings. Total attendance 17,095.

It is worthy of note that these meetingswere not confined to any particular section of the Jews in this country. For thefirst time, probably, in the history of thismovement, the so-called camp of opposition gave welcome and an attentive ear.This is especially gratfying because, if ourmovement is to have the desired standingin this country, it must be taken up by allclasses, and not confined to any particularclass. It must give us the greatest ofsatisfaction to know that in no instancewhere opportunity was given to your servant to present our side of the case, wasthere any other than a favorable response.That this response did not always assumetangible, financial form is not to becharged to the people, nor perhaps, to theChairman of the Propaganda Committee,but to a multitude of reasons, personalor communal. But this much is certain:Opposition, in an active form, rarely manifested itself. The instances where it didmanifest itself were so rare as to be noteworthy.

The stress that is being laid on the work done among the so-called Reform communities is not unjustified, when it is considered that outside of a few of the larger Eastern cities, the majority of American Jewry is either affiliated with the Reform Temple or predisposed in favor of Reform. Why this is so, it is not the province of this report to discuss. Only the fact can be set down. And, it must be borne in mind that in and around the Reform Temple are in most instances to be found those Jews who have progressed beyond the acute struggle for bread and butter, who have established themselves and are in a financial position

to lend strong support to any cause which meets their favor. The natural sympathy of most Jews with the Jewish National Ideal must not be depreciated, but it is not to be expected that those shall give as liberally to any cause, as those who are not recent arrivals, and are happily emancipated from the "Sturm und Drang" that is the lot of those who still have to make a place for themselves. Many beautiful instances of self-sacrifice on the part of mature Zionists for the sake of Zion might be narrated, and some of the most charming experiences of the writer of this report, the expression of devotion, the deep-felt grief over inability to make larger financial contributions, might be told. And, so, too, many pleasant things could be said about the so-called Reformers. Always, in every city, in every community, and by either class, the propagandist was received as a guest. His welcome was of the warmest character, and he had the unique distinction of being tendered banquets which he, however, always regarded as an expression of devotion to the movement. Yet again, the opening of the doors of Reform Temples to your representative must be referred to, because in every instance it was due to the courtesy of the Rabbi, who might be termed the "natural enemy." I wish here and now to make acknowledgement to a class of leaders who often went out of their way in order to give the Zionist movement a fair hearing. It must be borne in mind that no criticism could be made if they had declined to grant the requests, either of the Federation office or local committees. They were in no wise called upon to permit the advocate of a cause to which they are supposed to be in opposition, to contradict them. Often, they had seemingly to stultify themselves in extending an invitation to the Zionist, and as often to permit their congregations to listen to a more or less convincing argument in contradiction to what they had said about Zionism. But with rare courtesy, all such considerations were brushed a-