The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 1 · July 1909
16printed page
scan 16 of 60

lishment of a paid Secretaryship was undertaken to some extent as an experiment. The time that I have spent in the work of the Federation has convinced me that a permanent Secretaryship is a necessity for the Federation at its present stage of development, and will become more and more so as the`work of the Federation increases. Any suggestion, either of a return to the plan of a voluntary Secretaryship, or of a merging of the work of the Secretary with that of any other officer or`committeeman, seems to me not to be based upon a careful consideration of the needs of the movement. The proper duties of the Secretary of the Federation are already quite sufficient to occupy one man's entire time and attention. Perhaps one serious objection to this plan is the fact that, for a time at least, the existence of a paid Secretary may have a tendency to cause the voluntary Committeemen and other workers to relax in the performance of their several duties; but this objection is only a temporary one, and in time the duties of the Secretary and of the various Committeemen will adjust themselves to each other in the proper manner. A more serious difficulty at the present time is the question of providing for the Secretary's salary, a thing, which, I have shown above, cannot be done by the societies as they are now constituted. The method adopted during the current year of establishing a Secretary's Guarantee Fund is out of the question for reasons that can best be made plain in a full verbal discussion.

To offset the difficulty, there are two considerations. One is that, should the Federation recognize the system of special membership and embody the same as a part of the general organization, the Secretary can be of great assistance in securing new special members. The second one is that a permanent Secretary, giving his entire time to the work of the Federation, can save the Federation a part of his salary, by taking over certain duties which, without him, would have to be performed by several persons at a considerable cost. He will also be in a position, as he becomes

better acquainted with the details and the needs of his work, to introduce economies in various ways. This possibility has already been proven beyond doubt during the current year.

In addition to these two considerations, I would suggest a third possibility, this one being involved in a suggestion made in a previous part of this report. If the principle is adopted that each fund defray the cost of its own collection and handling, and if it is recognized that the work of a permanent Secretary will contribute in a large measure to the increase of the various funds, there would seem to be no reason why these funds should not be made to pay their pro rata shares towards the total expense of maintaining the Federation, Secretary's salary included. To argue that this would be taking unjustly from these funds is to be blind to the simple fact that with a strong Federation, and with at least one officer devoted entirely to the strengthening of the various Zionist institutions, these funds and institutions are bound to prosper to an extent that is otherwise impossible. To continue our present policy would be anything but the practice of economy.

Reviewing the work of the Federation during the past year, and summing up in a word, it can be said that the year has been a successful or a disappointing one, according to the point of view adopted. If the measure of our progress consists in the number of meetings held, speeches delivered and long notices received in the general press, the Federation has not made much progress since the last Convention, excepting in the work done by Mr. Fromenson, and to a smaller degree, in the work of Mr. Frankel, and a number of volunteer speakers who are too numerous to be mentioned here. If the measure of progress be one of increased interst in th aims and policies of Zionism, decrease of opposition to our movement, growth of the more important funds and institutions of the movement, then the results have been satisfactory as compared with those of preceding years. But I feel assured in saying