The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 6 · June 1909
207printed page
scan 9 of 52
THE MACCABAEAN
207

Zionist, who will not offer his congratulations for having alighting on terra firma so close to our own Palestine. Zionists will wish him the fullest success, and we shall consider ourselves fortunate should the required forty million be forthcoming.

Mr. Zangwill deserves praise for the energy, the audacity and the great patience, which he has brought to bear upon the problem, with which he is busied. He is industrious in the cause of the Jewish peo. ple; he possesses great talent in the presentation of his plans and in the persuasion of those Jews of great means, upon whom, as yet, the deeper sentiment of nationalism has made no visible impress.

But, if we refrain from offering a word of criticism of his latest scheme, we are not justified in neglecting to point out a certain peevishness, a tendency to boastfulness, and a certain petty partisanship, which discloses itself in his latest utterance.

As the leader of an organization that prints its Blue-books, and understands the intricacies of diplomacy, it seems to us Mr. Zangwill would refrain from a criticism of the organization of which he is still a member. It does not help that unity, which he claims he is seeking.

The shortcomings of the Zionist movement are the shortcomings of the Jewish people. Mr. Zangwill may have forgotten the first principles of Jewish nationalism based on democratic ideals, but Zionists who appreciate the great task before the movement, are not eager to place the blame on the shoulders of the organization, which is devoting itself to the best of its ability, and as far as its means allow, to the awakening of the Jewish masses to the solution of their national problem. Had Zionism gone the way of Mr. Zangwill, and deliberately abandoned the idea of moving the Jewish people without the aid of the great millionaires among us, it might have become quite as fashionable in upper circles as Itoism is to-day in England.

But the Zionist movement has remained true to its first principles. It seeks, not

the colonization of a land, but the cultivation of a people willing and anxious to exploit their own national soil. The millions may not be ours, but we hope to win the people, which is now a secondary consideration with Mr. Zangwill

We expect from Mr. Zangwill less whimsicality and more candor, less epigram and more good sense, when he discusses as head of an organization, the affairs of another organization which is just as earnest, just as competent and just as devoted as he himself may be to the cause of the Jewish people. To charge the Zionists with having no handbook on Palestine, and then, in the same paragraph, admit that we have two, one an "excellent" one; to admit that we have handbooks, but to reduce their value by saying, in the very same paragraph, that it is not an official publication, is a bit of pettifogging, which one does not expect from Israel Zangwill. To say that there is not a single Zionist plan for any of the area open to the Jewish Colonial Trust, and neglect to mention the score of activities the Zionist organization has set in position, is deliberately unfair.

It is true, we have no plan, but "some activity" is better than a plan with no activity. It is true we have no Blue-book, but we have no need for Blue-books; we have national funds, a Jewish Colonial Trust, in good working order. It is true, we have few millionaires, but we have collected from the people a few millions more than Mr. Zangwill's own millionaires have given him. To criticize us for not having a plan, and then, as if to show us how to do it, to present a plan which even when it is presented is tentatively withdrawn, is not at all the method used by any one who is determined that his eloquence shall outlast the sounds of his own voice.

While we are glad that Mr. Zangwill has alighted so close to Palestine, with a plan or without one, in good or bad spirits, we must point out that the Ito organization cannot be included from this time on among our nationalist organizations. It makes no provision for the co-operation