MR. SCHIFF ON ZANGWILL'S SCHEME
The New York Times gave a summary of an interview with Mr. Jacob H. Schiff, which has appeared in the London Jewish Chronicle. In this interview Mr. Schiff discussed the subject of Mesopotamia, and declared that he had no sympathy with and would not take a hand in any scheme involving political conditions, such as the formation of an autonomy of any kind.
Explaining his identification with the Mesopotamia scheme, Mr. Schiff said:
"All that I am responsible for is that in an informal discussion, I expressed my belief, based upon information, in the desirability of opening up Mesopotamia and the Euphrates Valley to Jewish settlement; but I have given an emphatic opinion that it this huge scheme —and it is a huge scheme —is to be considered at all, it cannot be the scheme of any one organization, but various large organizations must co-operate in a careful examination of the proposition"
"Would a conjunction of Jewish organizations be able to cope with the scheme? Mr. Schiff was asked.
"I am afraid that would not be possible," he said, "for a great amount of money will be required for the proper irrigation of the country, which must perforce precede any settlement there. That cannot be effected through private resources that are or are likely to be at the disposal of Jewish organizations. It would be carried through successfully only if aided by a Governmental subvention."
"What do you call a great amount of money, Mr. Schiff?"
"Well, $200,000,000 or $250,000,000 is, I suppose, the least that could be expected for the necessary irrigation of the Euphrates Valley."
"Surely a settlement in Palestine would be cheaper."
"I understand your point," said Mr. Schiff with some energy. "You mean that being cheaper, it would seem easier of realization, and hence any such scheme would
be more practicable. But, in my opinion, the carrying out of the proposition in regard to Mesopotamia would be preferable to the promotion of any large influx of Jews into Palestine, where the conditions are not at all what they should be."
"Are they quite unalterable?" he was asked.
“Oh! no. I want to see conditions under which the Jews to-day live in Palestine improved and bettered—no one more than myself. I should like to see more schools there, especially for technical education, and gymnasia; in fact, everything that can tend to raise the condition of our brethren there.
"But I am strongly opposed to anything like the establishment of a State in Palestine. It is my firm belief that the new conditions in Turkey, where Jews have always been specially favored and where they are likely to occupy prominent places hereafter—for they have, it is said, considerably helped to bring about the regeneration of the Ottoman Empire now going forward—will not be favorable at all to a propaganda for re-establishing the Jewish nation in Palestine. It is certain to be resented by the Turkish Nation under the new regime. The latter represents nothing to so great an extent as the strengthening of the integrity of the Ottoman Empire."
"But would not the establishment of a large colony in Mesopotamia on the basis of autonomy induce equal resentment?" was the last question.
"I have no sympathy with and will take no hand in any scheme involving political conditions such as the formation of an autonomy of any kind. I would have the Jews go to Mesopotamia as they do to America—to the former instead of the latter because, with the Mesopotamian scheme of irrigation carried out, their opportunities would be so much greater. I am in no sense a Jewish Nationalist. I believe, indeed, that the continuance of the endeavor to re-establish Jewish nationality, is not unlikely to work, sooner or later, immense harm to the Jews—in Palestine in particular—and seriously impair the favored position the Jews in Turkey now occupy."
