The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 6 · June 1909
235printed page
scan 37 of 52
Facsimile · scan 37 of 52
Scan of p. 235
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE CONSISTORY OF PARIS

The annual meeting of the Jewish Consistory of Paris, was held on May 17, and a number of interesting facts were noted. Out of 3,666 members, only 280 attended, and about 1,000 more sent their proxies to the Executive. Since the separation of the churches from the State, there are many matters of vital interest which demand the closest attention of the members of the community, the future of which appears to be seriously compromised. The chair was taken by the Vice-President, Baron Edmond de Rothschild.

The financial statement which was presented by M. Alfred Neymarck, showed that the increase in expenditure had not been met by increased income, although the membership had risen since 1906 from 2,595 to 3,666. For many wealthy contributors had died in the interval and they had been replaced mainly by persons who cannot afford large sums. The expenditure, which exceeded 850,000 francs, will be still higher in 1910, as then the allowances for rent made by the municipality to ministers of religion and the grants from the State to rabbis will cease. Repairs to buildings will also have to be undertaken and other fresh items will help to swell the expenses. On this point M. Neymarck made some very disquieting observations.

Baron Edmond de Rothschild also dwelt on the serious financial aspect of the community and urged the members to contribute more generously so as to assure the maintenance of the community. He emphasized the twofold duty of the Consistory, namely, to provide ample synagogue accommodation, in consequence of the expansion of the city, and for the religious education of the young. He complained of the utter indifference shown in this respect by well-to-do parents, an indifference which should be urgently combatted, and he ended with an earnest appeal for the hearty co-operation of every Jew who was worthy of the name.

A lively discussion followed on the recommendation of the Council to alter the Constitution so as to permit of the admission of foreigners as members of the Consistory. The recommendation was opposed by several speakers, who maintained that a French community should be administered exclusively by Frenchmen. One of them—who is himself of Roumanian origin!—went on so far as to declare: “We are Frenchmen before we are Jews”—a statement which gave rise to considerable dissent. The representatives of the Consistory, among them M. Helbronner, who is auditor to the Council of State, showed that there would be no danger in welcoming into the Consistory foreign Jews who were capable of rendering services to Judaism. He added that the constitutions of protestant communities said nothing about the nationality of their administrators, and there was no reason why a Jewish body which had only to deal with religious matters. should continue to impose disabilities on any of its members. The meeting, by a large majority, adopted the recommendation of the Consistory, which provides that this body may contain as many foreigners as shall not exceed a fourth of the total number, on condition that these foreigners must have been members of the community at least five years and must have resided in Paris ten years. Other proposed amendments. in the constitution were also adopted.

The Association of French Rabbis met this month, under the presidentship of M. Alfred Levy, Grand Rabbin of France. These meetings have only been possible since the separation of the churches from the State, but the deliberations which have hitherto taken place have been so severely criticised by Rabbis in other countries that the question is asked: what effect would be given to these criticisms?

Last year, Baron Edmond de Rothschild, President of the Central Consistory. stated that he had gathered during his travels that foreign rabbis were hostile to any modification of the traditional princi-