The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 6 · June 1909
210printed page
scan 12 of 52
210
THE MACCABAEAN

and of the autonomous grouping of the various important nationalities in the Empire. It may, perhaps, be desirable to add that the pursuit of the Zionist purpose would not be radically affected if these prognostications were not to turn out true; but if, indeed, it shall be what Zionists hope and believe, if Turkey is to exist as a modern State, then great possibilities are opened up before us. Instead of dealing with an effete despotism, the Jews would form part of a modern State, while the demands of Greeks and Armenians would not only favor the Jewish desire for self-government in a small province of the Empire, but would even bring out into bold relief the peculiar loyalty which the Jews would cherish towards the dominant Turkish nation.

We are, indeed, still far from being able to take any action of far-reaching consequence on the strength of the changes in Turkey, nor is it very profitable to indulge in speculations as to the future. The positive work of the Congress, however, lies partly in giving a direction to the Zionist aim in Palestine, and we may be sure that this will be the most hotly debated point in the discussion of the Congress. It will replace the old struggle between the "practicals" and the "politicals," who waged such a strenuous fight up till the last Congress. Owing to the political metamorphosis, the "practicals" will now have it all to themselves. Alexander Marmorek and a few others still seem to keep up an intransigeant attitude towards the out-and-out "practicals" of the Ussischkin type, but Prof. Warburg, the head of the Palestine Department, is probably the most potent mediating force between the two sections. Unconcerned with the disputes of opposing factions, with no claim to authority and ascendancy, he pursues the even tenor of his way, creating one Zionist institution and strengthening another by his energy and influence. He is the most popular man at the Congress, not only on account of his personality, but by the work he represents. There can be no doubt that,

whatever the theoretical views of the "po-\nliticals," they are heartily and joyfully glad\nat any good tidings from Zion.

What is it that the Congress can demand of the present political situation, and what is it the executive can do? There may be doubt as to whether everything possible has been attempted, but none that something has been done. The movement is in the hands of men of energy and affairs, and is driven to action by the forces of a democracy. The establishment of the Anglo-Levantine Banking Co., in Constantinople last year, is clear evidence that the movement does not only mark time. but is progressing, and is endeavoring to get, and keep, in touch with all the factors at headquarters. The fact is that the old connections have now practically become of little value, and the uncertainties of the new regime in Turkey have created difficulties and obstacles in the way which must be taken into account in any legitimate criticism which one who feels a keen isterest in the advance of the cause may permit himself to make. We have all a right to dabble in politics, but it is necessary to remember that even in the most modern of democracies foreign affairs are left in the charge of those responsible for them. The advantages of serious criticism and fruitful encouragement which will be given to the Actions Committee in the debates of the Congress will, nevertheless, act as spurs to those by whom the movement is carried along.

The suggestions that will be made affect the present status of the Jews in Palestine and the relations of Zionism toward the Turkish nation. Now that the idea of pacific penetration is a general one, because the entirely changed conditions have made such a policy at once the best possible and the most desirable, it is the imperative duty of the movement to devote all its available forces to the strengthening of the economic, cultural and political conditions of the Palestine Jews. However trite and selbstverstaendlich such a demand