The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 5 · May 1909
160printed page
scan 8 of 52

soocieties. The income of the Verband for the year, according to the report submitted, was $615.00 and the expenses $371.00.

The executive committee recommended the erection of a Roumanian Hebrew Institute. A committee representing the New York Jewish Community was given the floor on the question of unity. It appears that the Shaarei Shomayim congregation, composed of Roumanian Jews, has serious objection to certain portion of the constitution of the Verband, and threatened to organize another Verband of Roumanian Jews. The matter being called to the attention of the Jewish Community, it was taken up by its Committee on Propaganda, of which Dr. J. Silverman is chairman. Dr. Silverman, accompanied by Dr. Pierre Siegelstein, Dr. Neuman, Bernard Semel, and Charles Altenkrug, appeared before the convention to suggest a plan to arrive at harmony. Dr. Silverman suggested that the convention and the opposition appoint each a committee of twenty-three, who, together with the committee of the Jewish Community, should work out a plan for co-operation.

Dr. MAGNES TO THE REV. LYNCH.

A reply from Dr. J. L. Magnes to the utterances of the Rev. Frederick Lynch, on the organization of the Jews of New York, appeared in the Evening Post of April 26. Dr. Magnes said, in part:

“The Jews have the right and the duty to organize themselves into as strong a body as possible. They must be organized both for the sake of their Judaism and for the country in which they live. Their Judaism requires of them that they be a race apart. It is generally accounted as an honorable thing if a man have race pride; and no less a man than President Eliot of Harvard has recently given voice to the sound doctrine that racial individuality is something worth preserving. The anti-Semite, however, objects to the race pride of the Jew, and objects to

the cultural values which this race pride has produced. The destruction of historic races is, however, not the only, and perhaps not the highest, conception of the future in America. The secretary of the Peace Society of New York City might consider the possibility of a variety of races' dwelling peacefully together and each of them contributing its share to the sum total of American culture.

Judaism, as the religion of a minority of the people, must, as must any other minority religion, have minority interests. If the Jews have any love of Judaism, and if they desire to preserve it and to develop it, they must, as a matter of course, organize. If bills are introduced into the Albany Legislature which the Jews regard as detrimental to their Judaism, it is a right and a duty conferred upon them by their American citizenship to protest and endeavor in every legitimate way to protect the specific interests of Judaism. The same would be true of any section of the community. The Jews do not believe that in developing their Judaism they are in any way untrue to their American citizenship. On the contrary, they believe that an organized Judaism is better for the country in which they live than a chaotic and disorganized Judaism.

"Mr. Lynch is really meddling in affairs that are not his own. The Jewish people is vexed by many problems—religious, educational, social, and economic. It is the judgment of large numbers of the Jews that these problems may be better solved by an organized Judaism than by a disorganized Judaism. The way we solve them, however, is not Mr. Lynch's concern. All that he need be concerned about is that we solve them, just as we Jews will be concerned as to Mr. Lynch's success in solving his own problems. We Jews shall continue to insist upon the rights of Judaism, just as we trust that Christians may insist upon the rights of Christianity. American citizenship, we are glad to believe, does not require racial or religious suicide."