The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 5 · May 1909
189printed page
scan 37 of 52

And what concession, what grant, what assurance have we received from Turkey that warrants this optimism on the part of our New Turkey Zionists? Have they offered us Zion under their suzerainity? Have they conceded to us local autonomy, have they granted us our own Assembly, or a per capita representation in their Parliament? No, none of these. What then has prompted this sudden love for a Nation that has held Judea from us all these years? What prospect do they hold out to us that should encourage many of our fold to sanction the union of our future with that of a Mohammedan nationalistic movement? Is it not strange, is it not remarkable, that all this optimism, all this enthusiasm, all this sudden affection for Turkey is based on a mere hope, on the success of the present party in power, on the vague promise of those who are at present leaders of this party? Is it possible that for such a hope, for such an irresponsible promise, we are ready to lay down our arms and take up the beggar's cup of dependence on Turkey?

Even granting the endurance of the present Democratic Government, what assurance is there, that the present party in power may not be overthrown. Granting faithfulness to the Turkish leaders who are buzzing hopes in our ears, what assurance have that their leadership may not be overthrown to-morrow?

We, of the affırmative, assert that a movement which has not as yet manifested its stability, with a party in power that maybe short lived, wth leaders who may be overthrown at a moment’s notice, with no legal declaration, grant or concession offered to us, with all these drawbacks, the present New Turkey movement holds out to us at present no hope for the restoration of ourpromised land.

We hold that our Zionists may obtain certain advantages due to the present crisis in New Turkey; but not along the lines our opponents would suggest: we ask no favors, no kindness, no charity from New Turkey; we ask for a mere business trans-

action, such as two equal parties may contract. Dr. Herzl continually sought to purchase Palestine for the Zionists from the Sultan. In this he was unsuccessful; but with the present regime in New Turkey; his policy may now be fulfilled.

No one can deny New Turkey is bankrupt. Money is her greatest need. We therefore firmly believe that if we could produce the funds, Turkey will gladly dispose of Palestine. We do not hold or desire to prove that the funds will be forthcoming, but that if the money could be produced it is more than desirable to take immediate advantage of this opportunity, which, once lost, may never return. It lasts not a decade, it is but an opportunity of the present moment.

Let us also forget that a Nationalistic movement is composed of energetic individuals. Turkey is no longer asleep, Palestine will no longer be asleep, the New Turkey movement will spread its energy in every portion of its domain. Palestine will be converted into a Turkish Province, just as every other portion of her Empire. Palestine is to-day isolated, open to Jewish Colonization, but to-morrow it will be Turkish. If we do not obtain it, Turkey will. If we do not obtain Zion now, we never will. When Dr. Herzl endeavored to purchase Palestine, it was a mere desire, now, it is a necessity. Then it was his great wish to obtain Zion, now, it is a danger that if we do not obtain it now it will be lost forever.

We Zionists must not depend or rely on. Turkey, until, whatever she may promise shall be guaranteed by a charter of rights, a legal document recognized by the World,

If undefended, if unprotected we march into the enemy's camp, we can expect nothing but to march under their yokes. If instead, we depend upon our own energies, if we strenghten our own movement, we will be respected because of our strength, our demands will be answered because of the power behind them.

GERTRUDE DAVIES.