The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 5 · May 1909
188printed page
scan 36 of 52
Facsimile · scan 36 of 52
Scan of p. 188
Text · transcribed from the scan

POLITICAL ZIONISM

CONTRIBUTED TO A JUNIOR Society Debate.

The Zionist movement has known its stress anl its strain. We have been excited by the Uganda Scheme, Ussischkin aroused us by lesser Colonization. To-day we are facing an even greater crisis in the New Turkish movement. New Turkey is echoed from platform and pulpit. New Turkey resounds from press and forum. Everywhere we turn there seems to be no other topic, all our hopes, all our ambitions, all our plans are becoming wrapped up in that one movement, New Turkey.

Let us pause and carefully consider this "New Turkey" craze. In its last analysis, it is but a rising of the Turks to found a National Democratic Government. In short, it is a Nationalistic movement of the Turkish People; and let us not deceive ourselves as to what a Nationalistic movement stands for. Nationalistic movements are no new events in History; we Jews have met them again and again in our marches of exile. The year '48 sounded a sote of freedom to the Jew, he believed his own emancipation was wrapped up in that of the Peoples of Europe. Now many young Jewish Hearts were aroused by a demand for a Young Germany, and were not their hopes crushed out at last by the cry or "Hep! Hep!" accompanied

The Literary Value of the Bible.

Moses-Lawgiver and Statesman.

Samuel Mohilever —his Life and Works. TOPICS FOR DEBATE:

Has religion done more for civilization than war?

REFERENCES:

"Jewish Encyclopedia," under Pentecost; Omer; Bible; Decalogue; Moses: Ruth; David; Mohilever; L. N. Dembitz, "Jewish Services in Synagogue and Home": Friedlander, "The Jewish Religion"; Morris Joseph, "Judaism as Creed and Life"; Henry George, "Essay on Moses."

by the most brutal voices, and by those very same Young Germans for whom our Jew sacrificed themselves? This same occurance was repeated in all the countries of Europe, and in our own times have we not witnessed the same event in Russia?

How many thousands of Jewish lives have been sacrificed in the Bloody Revolution for a New Russia, yet, were they not cast aside by this New Russia in the first and second Dumas? Did the Demiocratic Party utter one voice in defence of the rights of the Jew to equality? History teaches us that Russian Nationalism is for Russia, German Nationalism for Germany, French Nationalism for France, and Turkish Nationalism for Turkey. And we Jews must either become Russians, Germans, French or Turks, but under their nationalism we cannot remain Jews, we must become Foreigners.

In the present New Turkey movement must we agan tempt History to repeat itself? Must we be taught another lesson? Nationalism is narrow, Nationalism is bigoted, Nationalism is for one people, by one people and with one people, Nationalism is always Nationalism. It is so selfish we can expect nothing from it.

Why have the present Zionist movement? Was it not because we were unwelcome guests in the homes of the Powers of Europe? When were we aroused to a Jewish Nationalism? Was it not when we were slapped by every other nation, shall we now be enticed into the web of another Nationalistic Bogey, it is impossible for the Jew to learn by his past experiences, must we run through every flame and yet never learn that the fire burns?

Whn we think of the years of toil and struggle that we have given to build up out present movement, is it not pitiful to see our Leaders putting the entire structure in the care of the stranger, the gentile?

What faith we Jews do have in humanity! We have bent the neck for 2,000 years to the Christian, and now, after ten years of freedom, we are ready to bend our neck again to the Mohammedan.