The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 5 · May 1909
183printed page
scan 31 of 52

be but a still greater Ghetto of enormous proportions, with the same economic problems crying for solution?"

This question I am obliged to answer with a second question. What is a Ghetto? To my mind a body of Jews compelled to dwell in a certain district, recognized as foreigners, and limited to a few occupations and burdened with special laws applying to them only, constitute a Ghetto. Since Zionism strives to obtain a publicly assured and legally secured home in Palestine, it is natural that the Jewish people there will live wherever they choose to live, will not be foreigners but natives, will not be condemned to the push cart, sweat shop or pawn shop, but the great majority shall till the soil, like the natives of other countries.

In Palestine they will frame laws anl create conditions which will enable them to observe Jewish religion and traditions, to raise Jewish families and live a healthy Jewish life—if anyone desires to live such a life.

In Christian countries laws are enacted, that the Christian may live a perfect Christian life if he so chooses.

You say: "Conditions that have been brought about by centuries of circumstances can be undone in a similar length of time."

To this statement I desire to remark, that time alone will not cure these conditions, unless we eradicate the circumstances. We must cease to be a Wandering People, we must again settle down in a Land of our own and then the Jewish Ghetto problem will be solved. The tide of Jewish immigration will then turn towards Palestine. Even some of your New York Jews may feel tempted to fold their tents once more and return Home—to the land of their History, their Traditions and their Forefathers. In conclusion I

desire to say, my critic overlooks the fact, the crux of the entire problem viz : the annual influx of 80,000 immigrants.

Even taking for granted that the New York Ghetto dwellers should awaken some fine morning and begin spreading all over these United States, still the Ghetto problem would not be solved, for about 80,000 Jews enter New York yearly, and they will fill all the gaps created by those leaving.

Furthermore I believe that should large numbers of emigrants be removed from New York and vacancies created in the Ghetto, we have a surplus of millions more in Russia and Romania eagerly awaiting the opportunity to cast their lot in the land of the Free and the Home of the Brave.

It remains a season of trouble for the house of Jacob.

Henry FISCHLOWITZ.

St. Louis, Mo. April 14, 1909.

A FEW QUESTIONS.

To THE MACCABAEAN.

In the last issue of THE MACCABAEAN I note a very beautiful fable of "Animals." I should like to know from what Midrash you took it,—as those writings commonly known as "Midrash" (from which this purports to be derived) are centuries old, whereas certain expressions in this selection have a "modern" coloring. I was put to shame because I could not answer an interrogator. Some people get out of such predicaments by answering with manner of assurance "Midrash ha-Ne'elam." It certainly is surprising that S. S. Wise, quondam student of Columbia, should forget origin of "Temple."

Yours truly,

ARTHUR A. DEMBITZ.

Philadelphia, Pa.