The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 5 · May 1909
169printed page
scan 17 of 52
THE MACCABAEAN
100

twenty graduates of Jewish race and English nationality have repudiated Mr. Norman Bentwich's theory of the non-identification of the Englishmen of Jewish race with the Englishmen of English race, with all the prestige of their accumulated names, that I feel tempted to venture some observations on this most fascinating ethnological problem.

I should like first to remark that ourfive-and-twenty graduates are playing palpably, if none the less prettily, on theword “English,” when they retort to Mr.Bentwich, who used the word as meaning“racially English,” by themselves usingthe word as meaning “nationally English.”The chicanery, if I may employ the termwith respect, is obvious, for not even Mr.Bentwich would dispute it by the simpleprocess of paying a naturalization fee orbeing born descendant of one who haspaid a naturalization fee, any person,whether racially he be a Chinaman, anegro or a Jew, becomes from the purely political standpoint of nationality, anEnglishman. In spite, however, of thepayment of the fee, there still survivemany characteristics by which an admitted identification of nationality, notwithstanding the Jewish blood, distinguishedfrom the English blood. Your averageracial Englishman is slow, stolid and lacking in ambition; your average Jew isquick, nervous and aggressively competing. Compare on this point the academicand professional successes of Jews withthe academic and professional successesof Gentiles (why, Sir, one only has tolook at Mr. Bentwich and our five-and-twenty gentlemen) and it will be seenthat through sheer push and smartness weappropriate considerably more than ourdue numerical proportion of “pots, plumsand prizes.”

Further, while the racial Englishman is merely heavy and pompous, the typical Jew is obtrusively ostentatious, flaunting himself from Petticoat to Park Lane, through the intermediate stages of Houndsditch, Brondesbury, Maida Vale and Hampstead, in about the time it will

take one of his English analogues to effect the momentous migration from Lower to Upper Tooting. Again, while your racial Englishman is notoriously insular, your true Jew 's violently cosmopolitan; your real Englishman, moreover, is usually a Philistine, but nearly every Jew has some pretensions to being artistic. How many well-to-do racial Englishmen, again, lead the gilded life of sport and leisure, and how many well-to-do Jews? Is it not, indeed, fair to state that while the racial Englishman lives chiefly with his body, the Jew lives with his brain? Is not the distaste of the Jew for manual labor much more acute than that of the Gentile? And as for patriotism, have we not serious competitors to Trafalgar and Mafeking in Passover and Chanucah? In this context I appeal to more expert authority for information as to whether from the official standpoint we are justified in allowing our blood to thrill quite as violently for the victories of the country whose nationality we have only recently purchased, as it does for the victories of that race, the genealogical membership to which, is according to the official theology our chief claim to divine grace. The beauty of the position can, perhaps, be seen more clearly if we take the hypothesis of a Jew living the patriotic life in some future Egyptian State. Take, in particular, the Passover period, which, according to the logic of our five-and-twenty gentlemen, should be a hybridi-zed compound of mourning and mafficking when the triumphant laughter on behalf of racial ancestors should be duly tempered with the tears of sorrow for the defeat of “national” ancestors at their very hand.

A yet further distinction: the racial Englishman thinks it no shame to marry a racial Englishwoman; your true Jew considers it a serious offence against the Deity, let alone a mesalliance. Of course, intermarriage is becoming increasingly fashionable among the more advanced circles, but your ordinary Jew would sooner his son marry the most blatant chorus-girl or the most violently atheistic socialist, so long as he belonged to the Jewish race,