The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 5 · May 1909
168printed page
scan 16 of 52

ideal; and their action is so far justified. But it must not be overlooked that the points made by them are directed, not against "Zionism at the Universities," but against Zionism as such. Zionism means one thing, and one thing only, the world over, inside and outside the precincts of an English university. I beg leave to point out, once for all, and with all possible emphasis, that the quotation with which last weeks letter opens is applicable to Zionist thought in general, and cannot be made to refer to a psychological state peculiar to Jewish undergraduates.

So much for the student. But, on the general issue, may I, with all deference to the views of distinguished men, submit that the case sought to be made out against Mr. Bentwich is wholly or in part invalidated by a misinterpretation of his meaning? His point is that the descendant of Jewish ancestors has psychological and emotional elements in him which are not, or not in the same degree, present in the descendant of English (i.e., Saxon, Norman, Danish, &c.) or other non-Jewish ancestors—a view which few Jews could be prepared to gainsay. Last week's letter seems to make Mr. Bentwich say that a Jew cannot be an English citizen: that at least is the apparent implication of the following passage in paragraph (1): “We object to the distinction made between Jews and persons ‘born of English parents,’ for we contend that Jews can be, and are, born of English parents, even though their parents are Jews.”

The contention is one which Mr. Bentwich, who has, I believe, some acquaintance with the rudiments of English law, would be the last to deny. But it would seem that the phrase "born of English parents" has been taken from its context and used in a sense in which it was not meant by Mr. Bentwich. He was referring to differences of racial type, which do undoubtedly exist—not to differences of legal status and rights and obligations, which does not exist.

I respectfully maintain that this initial confusion of thought vitiates much of what

follows it, although I do not feel competent to examine adequately and in detail the various points involved. In regard to one of the contentions,—that of paragraph (2)—surely there is a general agreement that the Jew's religion is an attitude of mind towards the phenomena of life and experience as well as metaphysical speculation about God,—that it is a part of his mentality, of the essence of him; and, therefore, for the English profesing Jew to think exactly as his non-Jewish neighbor does—i.e., to be "entirely English in thought"—is in the nature of things impossible.

The most significant feature of the manifesto is the attention it pays to the feelings of "Englishmen of other creeds." There seems to be a fear that the language of Zionism will be interpreted by the man in the street in terms of treason to England. Here, again, one finds emerging the notion that the Zionist movement is only a few months old. The non-Jewish public has had many opportunities for trying and pasing judgment upon the movement, and the verdict will be found to have been almost always favorable. In England the movement is regarded as a sign of life in a somewhat spiritless, not to say parasitical, people, as a moral straightening of the back, and, in any case, as a serious attempt, honestly made, to solve a serious problem. In the other English-speaking countries Zionism is regarded even more sympathetically. And why should it not be so? So long as it is not misrepresented, Zionism can have nothing to fear from English public opinion. The signatories of last weeks letter have bowled down a ninepin of their own setting-up.

The writer of the last letter was Mr. Horace B. Samuel, who said:

TO THE EDITOR OF THE "JEWISH CHRONICLE."

SIR,—I feel so interested in the letter in your current number in which five-and-