The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 5 · May 1909
167printed page
scan 15 of 52
THE MACCABAEAN
167

can quite conceivably arise in which Zionists would be brought face to face with a sharp conflict of duty. They would have to elect whether they would play the part of good Zionists or good Englishmen. There would be no middle course. To my mind, men who knowingly join in a movement pregnant with such posibilities, cannot expect to be regarded as good English citizens, and consequently merit the disapprobation of all Jews who, although not "complete Englishmen," can justly claim to be considered good and "complete English. citizens."

The third letter was written by Mr. Walter Nathan, who said:

TO THE EDITOR OF THE "JEWISH CHRONICLE."

SIR:—Yielding to no one in love for England and in the wish to share her joys and sorrows, I have read with great surprise the letter of protest, signed by twenty-five University men, against Mr. N. Bentwich's opinion, that Jews cannot completely identify themselves with the English nation.

To justify their protest they base it upon some feat of dialectic logic, and I doubt not that all the signatories now feel convinced that they have proved their case logically and saved Jewry—from their English point of view. Logic is a very abstract science; it may be useful in mathematical problems, but to apply it to the lives of nations is out of the question and simply waste of time.

Can a Jew admire the Coronation Oath and, to give only one instance, could a Jew feel like an Englishment were Parliament to abolish the Jewish mode of slaughtering cattle? It is but natural that we as Jews could not, and no Englishman—knowing us to be a separate race, with a great history of our own—would find this unnatural, or, to use the word again, illogical.

The mistake, which many of us Jews make—the twenty-five University men included—seems to be this: We do not seem to distinguish between the political status of a country, into which all of us should

and do join, and the historical development of a nation's life. Both play their part, and as England still prides herself on being a Christian country no Jew can be entirely English in thought. England has no wish to part with her traditions. Why should we Jews?

The fourth letter was written by Mr. J. Alexander, who wrote :

TO THE EDITOR OF THE "JEWISH CHRONICLE."

SIR,—The sting of last week's letter under the above heading lay in its tail. Such a pronouncement appearing above signatures, many of which are household words throughout the community, merits the gravest consideration of all English Jews.

One would conclude that only a sudden crisis in the fortunes of the community could have led these gentlemen—many of them so distinguished in their several spheres—to spend so much time and trouble—as presumably they did in meeting together, discussing the situation, and framing and publishing their views. Here, I submit, that Jewish sense of proportion, which, English though they are, I am sure every one of them possesses, has failed them. May I assure them that they are playing sledge-hammer to a very diminutive fly? “Zionism at the Universities” is a phrase which has latterly, by no virtue or vice of its own, acquired an unmerited vogue. Because a few comparatively harmless individuals. meet. together in each other’s rooms to indulge the pleasant fancies of immature youth, it appears that the fabric of Anglo-Jewry is tottering to its fall. The obvious retort is —the less the infection has spread the more desirable to stamp it out forthwith..

What, then, is the new disease which is corrupting "the rising generation of educated Jews." Is Zionism a new thing? Is a "Zionist student" a new phenomenon, a fin de siecle monster? The signatories of last week's letter, as opponents of Zionism, take a natural alarm at any apparent advance in the popularity of the Zionist