The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 5 · May 1909
164printed page
scan 12 of 52
THE MACCABAEAN

The first letter, in reply, was written by Mr. Norman Bentwich, who said:

TO THE EDITOR OF THE "JEWISH CHRONICLE."

SIR:—It is somewhat embarrassing that a statement which I made recently, in the course of an interview, has been taken so seriously by a number of prominent English Jews as to induce them to issue together a grave letter of protest. I ought, perhaps, to say that in making that statement I was not the official expounder of University or any other Zionism, and that in replying to the protest I am again speaking only for myself. It is possible that a more authoritative reply may be made to the manifesto, but I write at once lest my silence should be taken as admission and in order that I may clear up my own position and answer categorically the points made against it.

I had said to your interviewer that the main work of Zionist students was to foster the Jewish historic consciousness, but at the same time they had, in fullest measure, a pride in their English citizenship. I was then asked if they felt that they could completely identify themselves with the English nation and my offending answer was that as Jews they felt this was not possible. They could not be as entirely English in thought as the man who is born of English parents and descended from ancestors who have mingled their blood with other Englishmen for generations. The reason stated— which the protestors have ignored in their letter—was that Jews must have a feeling of sympathy and brotherhood with the Jewish people in other parts of the world, and moreover must in some degree remain socially separate to be loyal to their religion.

The protestors deeply deplore the statement that Jews can never be "entirely English in thought." and the distinction incidentally made between Jews and persons born of English parents. Now, I think it is fairly clear from the sentence which followed, that what was meant was:

(1) That by his relations to other Jews, the English Jew has interests and sympathies which are not shared by other Englishmen, and (2) that by his Judaism which is, or should be, woven into the texture of his daily life, he has a certain conduct of life, certain sentiments, and a certain outlook, which, again, are not shared. By virtue of these characteristics he cannot be entirely English in thought, "as English in aspiration, interest, and zeal, as those who are descended from ancestors who have mingled their blood with other Englishmen for generations."

"Englishman" is a word used in two senses; it means either a person who is a citizen of the English nation—and in this sense a Jew may, of course, be fully an Englishman and born of English parents—or a person who is a member of the Anglo-Saxon people as distinguished from a Welshman, a Scotchman, or an Irishman. Try as he may, a Jew cannot become fully English in this sense unless by intermarriage, he "mingles his blood"; and then he ceases to be loyal to Judaism. and his descendants will probably cease to belong to Jewry. Not only is the Jew different from other members of the nation in blood, but he has a history, a literature, a culture, and traditions of his own—these are among the chief elements of nationality which he does not share with other Englishmen; and he can only disown this splendid heritage at the price of disloyalty to his people and the certain disintegration of his religion.

Moreover, the Jew has a definite aspiration, which, be he Zionist or not, he cannot repudiate so long as he remains true to the religion to which it is essential. Here I do not trust to my personal opinion, but I will quote Schechter, who says: “The selection of Israel . . . the immortality of Israel as a nation, and the final restoration of Israel to Palestine, where the nation will live a holy life on holy ground, with the wide-reaching consequences of the conversion of humanity and