scent from the "haughty drunkerds of Ephraim," and I am sure that even "modern scientific research" has not enabled Rabbi Morgenstern to save this privilege for us. Accordingly, the only country with which we have to deal is that of the Judeans. What then are the facts which give Rabbi Morgenstern the right to speak with such sovereign contempt of the inability of our ancestors to take care of themselves?
Judah existed as an independent kingdom, after the secession of the Ten Tribes, from 933 to 586. During the entire length of these 347 years,—a term which ought to be sufficient as a period of test for a citizen of the New World.—we do not detect the faintest trace of a single civil war. During the whole period, beginning with the reign of David about the year 1,000 and ending with the destruction of the kingdom in 586, we do not hear of a single change, or a single attempt at a change, of dynasty, the only exception, which confirms the rule, being in the case of Athaliah, the daughter of Ahab, king of Israel, who usurped the throne of Judah and was overthrown by the faithful Judeans after an illegitimate rule of six years. The loyalty of the Judeans to the reigning house is overwhelmingly illustrated by the fact, unparalleled in the history of mankind, that twenty-five hundred years after its extinction the Davidie dynasty is still indissolubly bound up with the Messianic aspirations of our people. Surely, if self-restraint, discipline, respect for authority and its representatives be characteristics of the ability of self-government, then the genius of our ancestors did “lie in the field of self-government.” It is true, Judah never equalled, or intended to equal, the great military powers of Western Asia,—although it was never as small as any of the celebrated republics of ancient Greece,—but not becaus, as Rabbi Morgenstern so charitably puts it, “from first to last as a nation Israel was a most dismal failure,” but just because as a nation, as a community of common origin and common development, and as a nation only, did our ancestors care to perpetuate their political existence. It was only late
when the marshie birth; "such as did wickedly against the Covenant" (Daniel 11, 32) began to undermine the national foundations of the Jewish commonwealth and an anti-national dynasty usurped the throne of David, that the Jewish commonwealth actually became "a most dismal failure." It is true, the prophets frequently denounced the social injustice, the "bad government, tyranny and oppression" of the leading classes of Judah. But if we are to take our prophets literally, then our ancestors were just as void of a religious genius, which Rabbi Morgenstern is rightly anxious to emphasize, as of their ability or self-government. The ideals of the prophets were "so immeasurably in advance of the standards and capabilities of their ages and of succeeding ages" (compare p. 226) that they had to find fault with reality, and with all due devotion to this great republic of ours, whose genius, as Rabbi Morgenstern will surely not deny, lies in the field of self-government, we may safely assume that, were one of the old prophets to rise from his grave and be permitted to speak his mind, without being lynched,—he would scarcely be more complimentary than he was to our unfortunate ancestors.
This platitude of the Jews' inability of self-government is followed up by another, closely related to it and equally unjustified, ascribing to our ancestors a lack of patriotism.—towards Assyria or Babylon, perchance? Heaven forbid! For this Rabbi Julian Morgenstern, who is probably first American and then Jew, would consider an unpardonable crime,—but "only" a lack of patriotism towards Palestine, their own native land. "And finally," says Rabbi Morgenstern on p. 222, "we see Jerusalem captured and Judah led captive to Babylon, at first to mourn, but soon to recover from its grief, and so quickly feel itself at home in this new land that later when opportunity offered to return to the fatherland only the smallest fraction availed themselves thereof. Even then, twenty-five hundred years ago, the unifying and inspiring force in Judaism was not the land
