The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 4 · April 1909
153printed page
scan 37 of 52
Facsimile · scan 37 of 52
Scan of p. 153
Text · transcribed from the scan

tion be held no latter than the second week in June.)

Second, That the Convention be held in New York City. Carried.

The Convention Committee was instructed by the president to meet immediately and to take the necessary steps to carry out the above resolution. He also asked the Committee to consider the allotment of some time to discussions of an educational character.

Organization:

Mr. Schneeberg suggested that a plan of reorganization be presented to the Convention by the Executive Committee as ordered by the past Convention. Mr. Joseph here stated that he contemplated the calling of a conference at a very early date to consider methods of reorganization and also the revision of the constitutions.

Shekel:

Mr. Joseph called attention to what he considered the present unsatisfactory arrangements for the sale and control of the shekel receipts. He urged that a single individual ought to be in charge of the shekel work, preferably a member of the Executive Committee, who would devote all of his thought to this work. After some discussion, Mr. Joseph put the following motion :

That a committee be appointed to consider the sale of shekolim, and that this committee have power to take such action as will increase their sale; and that this committee, furthermore, study the subject and prepare itself to give definite recommendations to the Convention. Carried. Committee appointed: Mr. Joseph, Dr. Epstein and the secretary.

The secretary announced that the offices of the Federation would be removed to 200 East Broadway on May 1.

A CRITICISM OF MR. KOHN'S ARTICLE

To THE MACCABAEAN:

Concerning the question of Jewish Education in America, which was raised in THE MACCABAEAN last month by Mr. Eugenc Kohn:

It seems to me that whenever a living question is taken up for discussion by any one, he should not sit down and reason it out theoretically only. We are living in a practical age, and practical we must be in all our judgment. In the failure to apply this rule can be traced the error into which Mr. Kohn has fallen, and therein lies the reason for some of his absurdities.

The three agencies which, according to Mr. Kohn, "have exerted their greatest potency on the child" are the home, the school and the synagogue. "The home," says Mr. Kohn, "can be the chief educational influence," and so goes on to tell us how well it could become the greatest factor in the bringing up of the Jewish child. But Mr. Kohn ignores entirely the fact that economical conditions in America are such that the home cannot do anything toward educating' the child. Is not every father busy at his work all day, and some evenin the evening? Is not every mother occupied with odmestic duties? When the father comes home on Friday evening he is not inclined to "welcome the Sabbath Bride" for he knows that a day of labor awaits him on the morrow. It is very well to talk of "the distinct Jewish atmosphere in the home which, enhaled'by the child, becomes part of his organism," etc.

What good are these phrases?

Economic conditions in America will not change for our children's sake. We must necessarily turn elsewhere for the education of our children.

The old style Hebrew school, says Mr. Kohn, is a very poor place for children to learn, yet we dare not destroy it. "We must," to use his own words, "create in the children now attending our various Hebrew schools the craving for Jewish culture." How this can be done, when the