The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 4 · April 1909
149printed page
scan 33 of 52
Facsimile · scan 33 of 52
Scan of p. 149
Text · transcribed from the scan

out by the tumultuous applause of the Free Synagoguers.

Synagoguers.To avoid mistakes in the future in finding something in which to prove his deep reverence for Jewish things, Dr. Wise might turn to an etymological dictionary and find this: Temple, derived from the Latin, templum. Synagogue, derived from the Greek, sun and ago, a place of meeting. If Dr. Wise wants to get just a little nearer that reverence for Jewish tradition which he boasts on every occasion, why don't he call his place a Free Beth Hakeneseth?

JEWISH ASSIMILATION IN CHINA.

A writer in the International magazine (London) discusses the subject of Jewish assimilation in China with reference to the Jewish assimilation in the rest of the world. He holds it probable that the Jews of China are the descendants of the ten lost tribes of Israel. He contends also that these have become so completely assimilated, almost beyond recognition, to the Chinese because of the fair treatment they had received and because of the high ethical tenets which China . "not only taught and commanded but practically exercised." The inference of the writer is that "the success and failure of the Jews is not dependent on their own power so much as on the weapons and strength of their opponents," and that under similar conditions all other Jews would as easily and readily become assimilated as the Chinese Jews.

This is but another instance of how one will lose himself when he attempts to prove that the preservation of the Jew has not been due to an inherent power and a providential purpose, but to the mere force of circumstances. Assuming that the writer in the International is correct in his statement as to the degree of assimilation of the Chinese Jews, and assuming also that his supposition of the descent of these Jews from the "Ten Tribes" is true, his inferences and conclusions are certainly neither valid nor true. He seems to forget the vast difference between the tribes

of Israel and those of Judah. Still more does he overlook the dissimilarity between the Jews who were banished from the land by Shalmaneser and Nebuchadnezzar and those who became exiles through the instrumentality of Titus.

The mistake of the writer is, howeveı,easily explained. He labors under the erroneous idea that the Jew has been preserved solely and simply through his religious consciousness. This theory is altogether wrong. The preservation of theJew is not only attributable to his religious consciousness, but to an equal, if notto a greater, extent to his national consciousness. It is very doubtful indeed ifthe Jew had not entertained the hope ofrestoration, whether he would have beenable to maintain himself to this day, andit was just this element of national consciousness that the ten tribes lacked. Having separated themselves from the Davidichouse and from the national and national-izing capital of Jerusalem, they became laxin their nationalistic sympathies. Theseonce lost, it was but a short step whenthey were taken captives, to become assimilated to other nations.

Not so was it with the other two tribes. In these the nationalistic tendencies were stronger, and although they had become weakened in the short period of the Babylonian captivity, Ezra succeeded in restoring them. But the Jew did not rise to the full strength of national consciousness until he had gone through the further period of development and experience during the second commonwealth. It was then he had his Maccabean warriors and heroes to whom liberty was nearer than life, and to whom home was dearer than Heaven. So, when he was again taken from the sacred soil, he left Palestine fully confident that his exile was to be only a temporary one; and why should it have been otherwise? Had he not once before seen his country fall before his eyes? Yet he found the means of returning and re-establishing himself. Why, then, should a second return and re-establishment be precluded? No! it might take some time, even centu-