The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 4 · April 1909
144printed page
scan 28 of 52
Facsimile · scan 28 of 52
Scan of p. 144
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Hebrew Drama. Baron Moritz de Hirsch —A Biography. Jewish Charity—A Historic Study. The Jewish Colonization Association.

Topics for Debate:

Would the ICA fulfill the will of the late Baron de Hirsch by promoting colonization in Palestine?

References:

Jewish Encyclopedia, under Omer; Omer, Lag be; Luzzatto, Moses Hayyim; Hirsch, Baron Moritz; Hirsch Fund; Agricultural Colonies in the Argentine Republic. Friedlander, The Jewish Religion, p. 392; O. S. Straus, in the Forum, July, 1896.

Junior Society Debates

To THE MACCABAEAN:

In the last issue of THE MACCABAEAN there appeared an article on Economic Zionism, by Miss Fannie Hick, which expresses the idea of the Political Zionists. I frankly admit that such arguments to-day, considering the political change in Turkey, are beyond my expectation. Miss Hick urges us to put aside our present plan of working for Zionism, and concentrate our energy to secure a charter, which was likewise the sole object of Dr. Herzl. There is an old saying, "All roads lead to Rome"; but the question is, which is the shortest road to the realization of our ideal. It is true that Dr. Herzl concentrated all his energy to obtain a charter, but it is equally true that we notice with the deepest regret how much nearer we would have been to the realization of our ideal if Dr. Herzl and all others spent all their energy in what we consider to-day practical work. If they did we would most probably have to-day a half a million Jews in Palestine, with which number we could have positively obtained autonomy, which is practically the basis of our ideal.

It is absurd to think of a charter, when the people for whom the charter is intended are scattered over all the continents. Let us have a sufficient number of Jews in

Palestine and the charter or autonomy will be easily obtained. If Miss Hick doubts the success of the Constitution in Turkey, and therefore believes that in case this Constitution is of short duration, we should have a charter as a safeguard against the government, it is a mistake, because the charter will be of little value then.

Have a strong Jewish population there,let them work for the restoration of Palestine, and show that they mean to prepare Palestine for the future home of theJewish. nation, and capital will come. Itwill have to come, if not for the sake of anideal, then for the sake of business enterprise.

SAMUEL BORSON

New Britain, Conn.

[The article by Miss Hicks should not be taken seriously. It was an argument in a formal debate, and Miss Hicks must have been compelled, in order to maintain the position of her side, to go a little beyond the facts. The debate was held by Junior Zionist Societies.]

The Stamford Zionist Societies

In the little city of Stamford, with its Jewish population of about two hundred families, there now exists two Zionist societies. They are the L'man Zion and the B'nei Zion Lodge.

About seven years ago the well-known Zionist, David Cohen, organized the L'man Zion. Though starting with but a membership of seventeen, this society now numbers seventy-five good standing-members. It is an active Zionist society, not only spreading the doctrines of Zionism in Stamford, but also in the surrounding towns, where mass meetings are held and shekolim collected. During the seven years of its existence it has contributed hundreds of dollars to the National Fund, sold one hundred Colonial shares and one hundred olive trees, has contributed to the party fund, and has collected about two hundred shekolim annually. It has also organized a branch of the Bezalel, contributing the sum of fifty dollars yearly to this school.