The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 4 · April 1909
130printed page
scan 14 of 52

In the United States, numerically, there are three-quarters who still believe in the ancient doctrine; those who remain are equally divided between Jews of the Silverman persuasion and Jews who are nationalists, and Jews who are utterly indifferent. The same analysis holds good with Austro-Hungary, with Germany and with England.

It may therefore be safely assumed that two-thirds of the Jewish people believe in the orthodox form of Judaism, one quarter believe in a national regeneration, and the remainder are divided between the reform Jews and the indifferent.

Nor are all reform Jews favorably disposed to denationalized, assimilating reformation. In Germany there are thousands of reform Jews who have come to a reconciliation of their religious beliefs and the national interests of the Jews. The same holds good here in America. Many reform Jews, finding that it is impossible to progress very far while the Jewish problem is so complicated, finding that their religious principles lead only to indifference and apostasy, have felt that the national movement among the Jews deserves their support, not only for the sake of those who are persecuted in the name of Judaism, but also as a measure of self-interest.

Nor are the advocates of a superior monotheism and a perambulating mission, quite consistent in their own practices. You will find them instinctively adhering to customs that are purely national; they celebrate holidays that have no religious significance, but are essentially national. In New York, at present, there is quite a scramble for the celebration of such holidays as Purim, Chanuka—Passover—and though the reform wing seeks to give these holidays their own interpretation, they fail lamentably in separating the national from the religious influence. Purim is a national holiday, for it celebrates the escape of Jews from a national calamity. Chanuka is the celebration of a people who then overcame their enemies in pitched battle and therefore rejoiced. Inasmuch as the reform Jews do not believe in miracles, they cannot avail themselves of the

miraculous burning of the oil as of religious significance. Passover is the holiday of liberty. It celebrates the winning of freedom by a people that had been in slavery. This people's God had saved them, He had made the nation free. What solace can a reform Jew 'find in the festival of national freedom, if he does not believe in the national interests?

There are no Americans by race. America is the meeting-place of the nations of the world. Ask a German, what is his nationality, he will tell you it is Germany. Ask the Irishman, he will say it is Ireland, and he still gives his money to help free Ireland. Ask the American-Swede what is his nationality, and he will tell you it is Sweden. Ask the Russian what is his nationality, and although he is there oppressed, restricted, held under the heel of a despot, he will say Russia! Ask the Jew what is his country. Will you have him answer he is a Russian, a Roumanian, a German, a Frenchman? Russia treats him as a pariah, shall he claim a Russian paternity? Germany holds him under police surveillance; restricts him in petty, irritating ways; shall he, forgetting the indignities heaped upon him, still claim Germany as his fatherland? In order to occupy a place in the America where the races of Europe meet, the Jew, as a self-respecting citizen, must claim that he is a Jew by nationality. If he does not do that he is an American citizen with a blemish.

At least, for his own dignity's sake, the Jew in America ought to claim a Jewish nationality in preference to one that implies previous homage to a nation that despises and persecutes him.

But we comprehend the motives that prompt the ignoble of our race to deny Jewish nationality. They know full well that they speak for themselves in all their utterances. They know that looking back upon Jewish life, looking at present Jewish life, looking forward to the Jewish life, searching the meaning of all that Jewish life has produced, the word nationality is written large over it all, subordinating