The fact is, Dr. Silverman speaks for himself. His Judaism is not based on nationalism, and has no connection with it. His Judaism is a deliberate giving up of all our ancestors have handed down to us. His Judaism would make of the Jews a mere community based on a faith that has been stripped of all its racial coloring. It is his own personal opinion, without one iota of evidence, without one historical fact, without one fact from the present-day life of the Jewish people.
You cannot formulate one set of dogmas, taken from Jewish life, that would not include a belief in the national future, and therefore the national present, of the Jewish people. Every tradition of Judaism, every hope expressed in the prayer-book that is used by a majority of Jews who do use prayer-books, is based on the hope that some day, miraculously or otherwise, the Jews who are in exile, will be permitted to return to the land of their fathers, where all the laws and practices, as ordained by authority, shall be free to develop.
And there is nothing essentially exclusive of nationality in the term religious community. A religious community may also be based on a national separation. That form of community was seen in England, where the Anglican Church, representative of English reformation, was practically the state religion. Then, an Englishman was not only a member of a church, but also at the same time, of a nationality.
Such, too, was the construction of the Jewish state. Judaism was not only the belief of a people in one God and in the law evolved from that belief, but it was also the state; the tenets of the religion were the laws of the state, and a good Jew was a loyal citizen of the Jewish state.
If history means anything, the Jews were a national group, descended from the patriarchs, who had lost their national home, and were doomed, for their sins, to continue in exile, until the Messiah would bring them back again. In that exile, they perpetuated their traditions; they sought to live, even as they had lived while in their own home. Necessarily, many of their
practices had to be abandoned, a number of them had to be crippled and re-interpreted, but at no time was the idea of the national return completely lost. It was the only reason for keeping up those practices. It was the only reason for continuing a separate people, governed by a national polity which could not safely be amended, or altered with ease in exile. For they were a nation in exile, and they were treated as a nation in exile. They felt that because of their national transgression, they were compelled to endure in silence; they did not help themselves, for they were inspired by the feeling that there must be a divine intervention, before they could return to their own land; they had faith in God in that day.
They never abrogated their national law. They amended it by casuistry, logic and commentary. There are innumerable instances of how, by intellectual ingenuity, they managed to retain national usages, in spite of adverse circumstances.
They aimed to perpetuate the national existence of the Jews, no matter how difficult it was, no matter how intricate their reasoning had to be in order to remain alive as loyal Jews, no matter how far-fetched their deductions were.
It is evident, therefore, that when the preachers of a limited Judaism speak of the Jews as a religious community, they are somewhat confused as to what they mean by the term, and moreover they disregard completely the facts of Jewish history.
Nor is it a fact that they speak for the majority of Jews, who in the last analysis make Judaism what it is. There are about eleven million Jews in this world, of whom over five million live in Russia, less than two million in Austro-Hungary, over one million in the United States, and a little over one-half a million in Germany. Or the Jews in Russia, it may safely be said, that one-half are thorough believers either in the Judaism of old, with a Messianic postlude, one quarter are believers in an active effort to realize the national hopes of the people, and the rest have no views whatever on Jewish questions.
