The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 3 · March 1909
111printed page
scan 33 of 52
Facsimile · scan 33 of 52
Scan of p. 111
Text · transcribed from the scan

titions may not convince the trustees of the nature of that opinion; but it is the duty of men charged with a mission, to endeavor to swim with the current of events, not to stifle it, or disregard it, or to act in autocratic indifference to its expression.

The millions of the Baron de Hirsch, sensibly used at the present time in Palestine, could solve all the problems that confronted Baron de Hirsch at the time he made the bequest to the IKA. If the IKA trustees were wise, patriotic, far-seeing, they would not wait for the prodding of a monster Jewish petition or the denunciation of Israel Zangwill, or the silent disapproval of hundreds of men and women interested in the future of the Jewish race, before they recognized their duty in Palestine and did it with vigor and intelligence and promptness.

THE NEW YORK KEHILLA.

The organization of the New York comimunity may now be taken as an established fact. After months of agitation, the Jews of New York have arrived at a realizing sense of the need of a united community for the betterment of local conditions.

Credit must be given to a number of men who have devoted so much of their time and thought to this end. Whatever the Kehilla may become, whether it will or will not realize the hopes of its leaders, they have done a great deal to make Jews here conscious of their interests as Jews, conscious of the need of an authoritative representative body, that shall conserve Jewish interests, and they have thus created the form which will be useful in the days to come for reaching the Jewish people.

Credit must also be given to the American Jewish Committee for its patriotic sub-ord'nation of partisan interests to the cause of Jewish democracy.

THE MACCABAEAN has been an unflaggingopponent of the American Jewish Committee on the ground that it had neglectedto realize a democratic plan of organization

for itself. That its first members were self-elected was not the point; that could not have been avoided, probably; but that it continued in its unrepresentative capacity to claim national jurisdiction, was sufficient ground' for the attacks made upon it by THE MACCABAEAN. Many Zionists have taken issue with us on that point. THE MACCABAEAN claims that it has acted in this matter in the interests of Zionism. The vehemence of our attacks was justified by the seeming official indifference of the American Jewish Committee to criticism.

The American Jewish Committee had the power to become a representative organization, but it refused to consider a plan presented to it with that object in view. It has since neglected its opportunities to do what its members always unofficially declared was its desire. Because it was not a democratic organization, and claimed national jurisdiction, aiming to displace the absurd Board of Delegates of the Union of American Hebrew Congregations, it was encumbent upon an organ of Zionism to protest, to ridicule, if necessary, the pretensions of the Committee; for it aimed to perpetuate the policy of having the Jews always represented by volunteer, uncontrollable individuals, who, because of their power, or their means, were always able to take the responsibility. The Zionist movement aims to shift the responsibility where it belongs. The Jewish people must emancipate themselves. They must do their own philanthropy; they must solve their own problems; they cannot let them go by default and rely on their own weaknesses. The bane of Jewish life has been this evasion of duties.

The success of Zionism depends upon our success in creating a Jewish democracy. All obstacles in our way must be fought. Whoever claims that the Jews do not know how to organize and must have a "court" Jew to represent them, must not be surprised if we Zionists refuse to permit him to labor under that delusion. Even if the Jews had become so weak, so ignoble, such supine wretches, that they could not be trusted to take care of themselves, we Zionists would