THE MACCABAEAN
Published once every month by The Maccabaean Publishing Company. M. B. Lande, President; D. H. Lieberman, Treasurer; address for the business of the corporation, 547 Broadway, N. Y.
WHAT IS TO BECOME OF THE HIRSCH MILLIONS?
The intention of a number of audacious Palestinians to petition the Jewish Colonization Association to divert its activities, and necessarily its funds, into the Holy Land, for the purpose of upbuilding the Jewish population there, raises a question as to whether there is any legal or moral obstacle in the way of the trustees of the IKA, which prevents them from recognizing the fact that the future of Jewish immigration lies in Palestine and Syria.
The purposes of the Jewish Colonization Association, as outlined by Baron de Hirsch himself, are these:
“To assist and promote the emigration of Jews from any part of Europe or Asia—and principally from countries in which they may for the time being subjected to any special taxes or political or other disabilities—to any parts of the world, and to form and establish colonies in various parts of North and South America and other countries for agricultural, commercial and other purposes.”
For this object Baron de Hirsch gavefirst $10,000,000, and, when he died, $45,000-000 additional. The entire capital of theJewish Colonization Association is Hirschmoney.
. The Baron de Hirsch did not wish to exclude Palestine from the field of his philanthropy is shown by the fact that he subventioned the Alliance Universelle Israelite, giving it an income of 400,000 francs for its work in the Orient. There is also extant a number of statements by the Baron that prove that it was only the unfavorable political condition of Palestine, at that time that prevented him from doing more for the Holy Land.
It is therefore quite evident that the articles of incorporation of the IKA, and the known wishes of the testator, both may be considered as giving the IKA ample power to engage in work in Palestine.
The trustees of the IKA cannot plead that they are prohibited, as trustees, from engaging in hazardous enterprises. The fact that the Argentine experiment was hazardous did not deter them from spending millions on an attempt to make Jews go to a country of which they had never heard. The Woodbine experiment was undertaken with a recklessness of consequences which is only now revealed. Woodbine is no more fit for agriculture than the desert of Sahara.
The work in Palestine has no disadvantages. The government is representative of the people; the Jews are given full and equal rights with all other citizens. German, Russian and French capitalists are taking advantage of the opportunities that are now before them. It would be more easy to persuade Jews to go to Palestine now than it was when they were persuaded to go to Argentine. It would be easier to supervise its work in Palestine than it is to do the same in Argentine.
The co-operation of the IKA is therefore asked not for hazardous undertakings, not for enterprises that are forbidden the trustees, but for work that is directly in line with success and with the intent and purpose of the founder of the corporation.
Why should the IKA persist in ignoring the Jewish people?
The movement eastward is bound to continue. It is becoming more and more difficult to get Jews to go to Argentine. The immigration work of the Baron de Hirsch Fund in the United States is rapidly losing its raison d'etre. If the IKA continues to disregard the obvious trend of Jewish affairs, and sticks to policies that have no popular sentiment behind them, it will inevitably cut lose from Jewry. It will have the millions of the Baron de Hirsch, but it will be unable to influence in the least the trend of Jewish life.
Action cannot be taken against the IKA to compel attention to public opinion. Pe-