PROFESSOR GIDDINGS ENCOURAGES ZIONISTS
"What is a Nation?" was the subject of a lecture delivered by Prof. Franklin H. Giddings, of the Columbia University, the socioligist, before the Collegiate Zionist League, on January 9, at Earl Hall, Columbia University.
Prof. Giddings pointed out, at the start, that modern science does not permit ot cut and dried definitions. Just as the biologist can no longer draw the line and say (because one form of life over-laps in similarity of structure another form), here ends this genus or there, that species or variety, so the sociologist cannot make sharp limitations in defining a term, especially one over the meaning of which much blood was spilt. Thus Prof. Giddings launched into his subject by offering one out of many possible definitions of the term Nation.
Professor Giddings showed that the old definitions of the term have proven unenable in view of the historical developments of the past century:
(1) In ancient times nationality was based primarily on blood kinship, but the constant immigration and absorption of populations showed that we must discover some other principle on which to explain it.
(2) As a result, we have the effortmade in the nineteenth century to explain it on a basis of "the scientific frontier" (attributed to Disraeli) or the occupation of a certain well-defined territory.This we may call the geographical explanation of nationaltiy.
(3) "What is a Nation?" is often explained on a pyschological basis, or as the sum total of characteristics of a certain aggregation of people.
History, however, has shown us that a nation may be great and have cohesive power without any of these supposed essentials. What, then, is the central point of nationality, the prerequisite of national existence? Many scientists would give various answers, but Prof. Giddings would attempt to give only one answer—his con-
cept of nationality. First,—it is "an aggregation of individuals having a collectivr will to live.” The second essential for nationality is the possession of a strip of territory—a part of the earth's surfac. which the people of the nationality are willing, ready and able to defend against enemies. That is, a people, to be a nation must have the power and the desire to drive off any enemy that may attempt to displace it from its territory. Consequently, no people can be a nation unless it have a virile agricultural, mining or sea-faring population. If the Jews are ever to succeed in establishing a nation in Palestine, they must build up a strong agricultural population, for they will meet with failure if they intend to build up a society living on its wits.
In answering the many questions that were put to Prof. Giddings at the close of the lecture, he said that a nation which had almost its political existence was dead, that such a group could be called a people, but not a Nation.
The people that is only :striving to obtain a territory for itself, but has no territory of its own. is a nationality potentially,—that is, in the making.
In answering a question on the tenacity with which the Jew looked forward to the restoration of his nationality as manifested in his prayers ("next year in Jerusalem"—etc.), the lecturer told a humorous story of a Southern negro, who advised his friend that he would never obtain the coveted roast turkey so long as he prayed. "God, send me a turkey." but that he must change his prayer to "God, send me to the turkey." Not by praying merely, can the Jew obtain his Fatherland.
Prof. Giddings thought that the re-establishment of the Jewish State in Palestine would be fraught with important consequences not only for the Jewish people, but also for the World. When asked whether the Jews would be a greater influential factor in the world's spiritual and intellectual progress when acting individually, or when in unison with their brother Jews in Palestine, the Professor answered that a body of people, acting
