how much time the child should spend in the Hebrew school. In order to teach the . Hebrew language, Jewish history, Jewish religion, etc., we need, according to Dr. Benderly—and I fully agree with him— about eight hours a week to be spent in the Hebrew school. But I hear the protests of horrified mothers urging the demands of the child. What about his music lessons, his dancing lessons, his French lessons, his health? All except the last of these objections we can dismiss as unworthy of consideration.. We cannot agree to let the “accomplishments” take the place of a real education in Jewish character and ideals, but the last objection cannot be so lightly dismissed. For our children have before them a hard struggle for their individual maintenance, and if we disable them for this struggle, they will surely be unable to take their part in the struggle for the maintenance of the Jewish nation. But, after all, eight hours a week need not burden our children, provided that the time is well distributed and that— which has not been the case heretofore—the work be rendered varied and interesting. Dr. Benderly also suggests that the Hebrew schools have morning sessions for at least a part of the summer vacation, the work of these sessions being adapted to the conditions of the season. There is in the end no real conflict on the question of time between the demands of the subject and the demands of the child.
But let us be somewhat more specific as to what our curriculum should consist of. There should, it seems to me, be three main branches of study—Hebrew, Jewish history and Bible, and I wish to emphasize the fact that Jewish history and Bible are not to be treated as identical. There are two reasons for this. The first is that the Bible contains besides Jewish history, much of Jewish poetry, legend and law with which our pupils ought to be made familiar, and the second reason is that by discriminating between the Bible and Jewish history we avoid leading the child into dangerous conceptions. Let me explain this more fully. When the child learns in the public school the history of
his own and other countries, he finds a relatively dispassionate narration in which miracles play no part, and which convinces him by reason of its resemblance to his own daily experience. When, then, he turns to what he has been taught as Jewish history, he perceives the difference, and he doubts. As he has been taught that the Bible is both authority on Jewish religion and on Jewish history, his doubt will extend also to the religious truths contained therein. The result of the old method of treating these two subjects as one is not seldom that we instill in our youth, instead of Judaism, scepticism or even atheism. This we can avoid by teaching our pupils to go to the Bible for their religion and to other sources for their history.
But we must not carry this discrimination too far. To the small child fairyland is as true as the life above us and miracles the natural order of events. Scientific history is more difficult to understand than myth and legend. Just as it is easier and better to tell the child, in answer to his questions, that thunder is caused by the collision of the clouds, than to give the scientific explanation of the same, so it is better to teach the simple stories of the Bible than the conclusions of historical research. The same method is used in the public schools. One of the very first things, for instance, that the child learns in United States history is the story of George Washington and the cherry tree, for which there is no historical foundation. Moreover, though the Bible cannot be made the text book of Jewish history it is by far the most important source book to which constant reference should be made for illustrative material. Nor should the teacher hesitate to point out in events of history the working out of those religious truths that the child has learned in his Bible study. The course in Jewish history, moreover, should not be limited to the Biblical period, but should extend down to our own day.
And now let us give a little attention to the method of teaching these subjects, for, though this is not the place fully to dis-