later life with a categorical "no." But we must not fail to give due emphasis to the beauty of the ceremony. Our children must be made to look forward with eager anticipation to the Seder feast, the building of the Sukkah, the Chaunkah lights, the Purim masquerade, etc. They must receive from us not only the yoke, but also the crown of the Law.
The home alone is not, however, adequate to our needs. There are many things that the Jewish child must know about his nation—its history and its culture —which parents have neither sufficient leisure nor sufficient knowledge to teach him. To impart these we need the Hebrew school.
But at present our Hebrew schools, withvery few exceptions, are utterly incompetent to discharge this office. Dr. Benderly, in a very able article on this subject,analyzes the present status of Jewish education in America, and discovers three different types of Hebrew schools, of whicheach is about as inefficient as the other—the Cheder, the Talmud Torah and theCongregational school. In the Cheder anumber of boys—girls are excluded—studyamid insupportable hygienic conditionsunder a poorly paid teacher, who knowsnothing of the needs of the young American, and is quite out of sympathy withthe life about himself and about his pupils.The Talmud Torahs are for the most partcharity schools, with all the defects thatusually attach to such institutions, of whichnot the least is that they are governed bylarge boards of directors whose only qualification for the task of guiding the education of our children is that they have themoney necessary for the support of theinstitution. The Congregational schoolssuffer most from too little time and fromincompetent teachers.
In fact, one of the difficulties of Jewish education in general is that the small salaries offered to teachers make it impossible for them to devote their whole time or their best energies to the work of Jewish education. Not until we can offer to Jewish teachers a career, if not highly remunerative, at least possible, will we ap-
proach the solution of the Jewish educational problem in so far as it rests with the school. Another almost universal defect is the lack of proper school facilities, such as light, cheerful rooms, comfortable seats, pictures adorning the walls, and the like. This defect is a very grave one, for we cannot afford to let the child's environment in the Hebrew school be less congenial to him than his environment in the public schools. Another crying need of all our schools is for better text-books, but I shall take up that question in more detail further on. On the whole, our present Hebrew schools are in such state that Dr. Benderly, the only scientific educator who has devoted himself to this problem, finds it not worth while trying to redeem them, and urges the creation of altogether new schools supported by the parents of the children who attend and conducted by men and women who have the double qualification of being good teachers and good Jews, steeped in Jewish culture.
Personally, I think that we are not yet ready to give up the• old schools. It may be urged that the same energy which we expend in trying to regenerate the old could produce more in the new, but it seems to me that, if only in order to arouse an interest in Jewish education sufficient to make the need for new and better schools felt, we must create in the children now attending our various Hebrew schools the craving for Jewish culture. even where we cannot, under present conditions, satisfy that craving. The next generation may then create those new and better schools which Dr. Benderly has in view.
But though we should not, in my opinion, reject the idea of reforming our present Hebrew schools, we must realize that the reforms necessary are general and involve many changes in the general management, curriculum and methods of instruction that prevail in them. In making these changes we must consider the demands of the subjects which are to be taught, and the demands of the child who is to be taught them.
Let us apply this test to the question of
