The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 2 · February 1909
42printed page
scan 2 of 54
42
THE MACCABAEAN

thing from the start, but it was puffed up into the semblance of life by the army of ranters, who contrive to hold the right to the pulpits of Jewish temples.

The trouble with the Jewish mission was that it was an unreal interpretation of the meaning of Jewish life, promulgated with a dishonorable motive. In their souls the Jewish missionaries knew that the theory that the Jews were chosen by God to live in goluth and to be a light to the nations, to whom they were to preach a pure monotheism, was an audacious brag, an artificial imposition on Jewish history, a contrivance to permit Jewish life to be sapped by assimilation without a struggle on the part of the victims. It was a contrivance to prolong the Jewish goluth by enertia. It was a conception which struck truth at no point in its career. It was something to which no honest, unprofessional Jew would subscribe. The Jewish mission was an apology for existence, which no dignified man or race or nation would ever consent to make. The mission of any individual, race or nation, is, first and last, to be true to its own self, which from the start was denied by the mission theorists.

Nor are the rabbinical exponents of race and national dishonor the only organized body in the field, pretending to speak for the Jews. The Union of American Hebrew Congregations met last month, and again the empty pretence was pressed to the fore by the same class of professional Jews, who have never understood the people whom they are supposed to represent, that the Jews are not a race or a nation, but a religious community. If the Jewish mission means anything, it should aim to express not only Jewish principles of religion, but the Jewish principles governing all the relations of man, yet every opportunity they see to limit the Jewish mission to something more ethereal, more unrelated to life, they grasp with the enthusiasm of makeshift statesmen.

When the Union of American Hebrew Congregations makes a declaration like that it does not go back to the records

for proof of its assertion; it does not consult the Jewish religion to see whether it is consistent with it on that subject, for its primary object is to lull to rest the slumbering national and racial feelings among the Jews, and thus make easier, from a crass material point of view, their present existence. When it speaks of religion, so obtuse are these professed theologians that they do not see that they are speaking of religion in the Christian sense, as a creed, which the Jewish religion never was, for it has always considered religion and life one and indivisible.

Wherever you see Jewish life in its undiluted, unassimilated state, no matter how deformed or abnormal it may be, it is always bounded in every detail by the Jewish religion, and there is no more un-Jewish conception than that the Jews can eliminate all national and racial elements in their lives and actually remain exponents of Judaism. In every genuine Jewish town, or community, the Jewish religion means law, civil and criminal, hygiene, charity and philanthropy, education; in fact, all of life is governed by this version of the Jewish religion, for the value of Judaism, its future development, as well as its past, lies in just this combination of law and life, which has made it an indispensable factor in the civilization of the world, and which the Zionist movement has come into being in order to conserve for future uses.

Dr. M. H. Harris, of New York, who for a brief period was regarded as somewhat of a nationalist, but who has since retired to reconsider the question and to listen to the dictates of an enlightened conscience, recently said that all Jews who have no faith in Judaism and do not practice it, should get out of the fold. That was a bold thing to say for a rabbi whose congregation stands so close to the precipice of advanced reform. Dr. Harris's audacity has not been denounced at it should be. His impertinence has not been called by its right name, and, although his views have appeared in print, not one of the many rabbis and prominent Jews of this city have been keen