The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 2 · February 1909
55printed page
scan 15 of 54
THE MACCABAEAN
55

venge that the servile, the inferior and the incompetent have taken upon the strong and successful. It is philosophy invented by a slave nation, by the Jews, and transmitted through Christianity to be a curse to the world. By its means the sickly and the poor entangle in the net of their cunning .their conquerors, and thus recoup themselves for their defeat in the natural struggle for existence.

Shaw, though not so violent against the originators of morality, is no less strong against the evil itself. A reasoned morality is absurd, and conduct based upon a conception of duty is ridiculous. Conventional morality is disgusting. Every action should be measured by its effect upon happiness. The golden rule is that there is no golden rule. "There are just as good reasons for burning a heretic at the stake as for rescuing a shipwrecked crew from drowning—in fact, there are better." Of course, Mr. Shaw does not mean that a shipwrecked crew should not be rescued from drowning. The absurdity lies in reasoning out the act as a dictate of duty.

These Hellenistic philosophers have not yet been raised to the rank of prophets in America. The struggle is not yet over. Hebraism still has its advocates, and one voice, though soon to be silent, still thunders from across the waters—that is Tolstoi's. The influence of the "unmoralist," nevertheless, makes itself felt. It trickles down through the bold investigators of new opinions to the great mass of readers, so that men will be found giving utterance to these views, as to many others, without having any intimation of their origin. The movement away from Puritanism in America, at any rate, is unmistakable, and such a movement must largely decrease the popularity of a poet like John Milton.

Mr. Howells, two or three years ago, before the official choir in praise of Milton had begun to raise its voice, lamenting the apparent decline in the number of the poet's readers, was surprised to learn from correspondents in different parts of the country that the situation was not so bad as he had supposed. This correspondent

and that affirmed that she was still reading Milton. There was no possibility of collusion between the deponents, and it gratified the essayist of the “Easy Chair” that so many independent spirits should without compulsion be reading this poet.

Mr. Howells' gratification must have been tempered, nevertheless, by the reflection that it had seemed, prima facie, reasonable to raise the question; whereas, had he started a similar one with reference to Tennyson, or Browning, or Shelley, or Shakespeare, it would have been necessary to get assistance in handling the mass of correspondence that would surely have descended upon him, the measure of the fame of these poets being so obviously the number of their readers. But of Milton, his boldest panegyrist has to admit that he is more admired than read.

If not read, why admired? It has be-become a fixed tradition that in Englishliterature next to Shakespeare comes Milton. “Nature,” said Dryden, “having doneher utmost in producing Homer and Virgil,could no further go, and to form a thirdpoet combined their qualities in Milton.”Shelley called him “the third among thesons of light.” Tennyson wrote:

O mighty mouth'd inventor of harmonies, O skill'd to sing of Time or Eternity, God-gifted organ-voice of England, Milton, a name to resound for ages.

Not to admire after these is to confess lack of taste and judgment, and the time was when "Paradise Lost" and the Bible almost equally shared the reverence of English readers. The Bible itself has waned in authority and influence, but "Paradise Lost" has immeasurably outstripped it in the descent to neglect.

This joint decline; one must suspect, is,at least in part, due to the same cause—the reaction against Hebraism. Thatwhich has shaken the Bible's hold upon thereligious consciousness of men has alsoweakened the plausibility of the epic basedupon Biblical mythology. But if one canappreciate Homer, Virgil and Dante without believing in the Olympian gods or ina material and intricately constructed