The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 2 · February 1909
51printed page
scan 11 of 54
Facsimile · scan 11 of 54
Scan of p. 51
Text · transcribed from the scan

prior lien upon their citizenship, which, if there would be a possibility for their desire and plans to become effective, would prevent them from maintaining allegiance to the country, of which they now claim to be good citizens. The Jew should not for a moment feel that he has only found an 'asylum' in this country; he must not feel that he is in exile, and that his abode here is only a temporary 'or passing one. If those who come after us are to be freed from the prejudice from which this generation is, not unnaturally, suffering, we need feel that politically no one has any claim upon us but the country of which, of our free will, we have become citizens, that even if we are Jews in faith, there is no string to our citizenship."

Many things are to-day condemned as un-American which are not acceptable to us, or which we cannot refute with cogent arguments, and in this way the term is often abused; but when this doctrine of Mr. Schiff’s 'was denounced “as fundamentally un-American in theory” it was done with express knowledge of American policies and ideals. As a matter of fact and record the whole tenor of American public acts and practices are in full accord with the principles that actuate the Zionists in their efforts to secure to the Jews of other countries an autonomous government and a secure home in their own land. Wihen our government forbade the French from lending aid to Maximilian in his attempt to subvert the Mexican republic, when it intervened to prevent Great Britain from enforcing its claim against Venezuela by arms, when it checked the atrocities of Spanish soldiers in Cuba, it was doing as a nation what we Zionists are trying to do as individuals. If our government thought it right to come to the aid of people so remotely related to it, how much more reason have we to strive for these who are of our own flesh and blood. With pride and reason we boast that our government is the first in the world, but that glory some would deny in order to find an argument against our cause.

Political allegiance to more than onecountry at a time is logically impossible,and the recognition of this fact is universal. We concede this freely and unreservedly; but our devotion to Zionism in nosense places a prior lien upon our citizenship. It is an obligation separate anddistinct from our civil obligations to thecountry of our birth or adoption, in sofar as any obligation can be so considered.But as a matter of fact, duties can not beso delimited; instead of forming singlebonds, between the individual and themselves, they form a plexus of relationships, a complicated web in the warf andwoof of which we weave our characters.Prof. Royce says, "In loyalty, when loyalty is properly defined, is the fulfilmentof the whole moral law." Loyalty to ourcountry does not require us to be disloyalto our family and its needs; to our religion; or to our brethren in distant lands.I thank God that our country demandsno such one-sided, narrow loyalty aswould be involved in this idea. In accepting American citizenship our fathers didnot barter away their liberty, but enteredinto possession of it; they were eager forit because they saw in it a means to accomplish greater things than they couldin bondage; and he is unworthy of thisprivilege who will so misconstrue its duties as to maintain that it is inconsistentwith the noblest ideals that man can nourish.

If the establishment of a Jewish state in Palestine should be inimical in the slightest degree to the interest of the United States, we might well hesitate to further such a cause; but who has the temerity to maintain such a thesis? Can the establishment of a new state founded on principles of liberty learned from the American Republic itself prove injurious to it? If so, we have already done ourselves untold harm in aiding and fostering numerous republics in this continent, and our policy has been radically wrong. This I can not believe, nor am I willing to put such a weapon in the hands of the tyranny.

Are we injuring our country by seeking