The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 1 · January 1909
4printed page
scan 4 of 50
Facsimile · scan 4 of 50
Scan of p. 4
Text · transcribed from the scan

Then follows the names of those who will sign the call for the convention: For American Jewish Committee—Nathan Bijur, Joseph H. Cohen, Daniel Guggenheim, Leon Kamaiky, Edward Lauterbach, E. W. Lewin-Epstein, Adolph Lewisohn, David H. Lieberman, Morris Loeb, Louis Marshall, H. Periera Mendes, Jacob H. Schiff, Isidor Straus and Cyrus L. Sulzberger. For Clinton Hall Conference—Joseph Barondess, Gedaljah Bublick, Samuel Dorf, Dr. H. G. Epstein, Harry Fischel, Rabbi Jaffe, N. Lamport, Dr. Moskowitz, Usher Marcus, Rabbi S. Margolies, Rev. H. Masliansky, Mr. S. Mosessohn, Louis Miller, Leon Moisieff, Dr. S. Neuman, David Pinski, Rev. Dr. A. M. Radin, Judge Otto S. Rosalsky, Prof. S. Schechter, Abraham S. Schomer, Bernard Semel, Dr. P. S. Siegelstein and Rev. Dr. J. Silverman.

This statement does not contain the provisions adopted by the American Jewish Committee, which relate to the limitations of the scope of the New York Kehilla, which are the conditions the American Jewish Committee has formulated as necessary to secure its sanction. We quote from the annual report of the Committee, page 39: "As such executive committee, (of the New York Community) they shall have jurisdiction over all questions of a local character, or which shall specifically affect the New York Community, subject, however, to the right of any two members of the executive committee, who shall be members of the executive committee of the American Jewish Committee, to appeal to the later from any action determined upon, if they shall certify that in their opinion the action proposed to be taken shall trench upon the jurisdiction of the American Jewish Committee, in which event a special meeting of the executive committee (of the American Jewish Committee) shall be held within ten days to consider such appeal. All action by the New York Community as to the subject matter of the appeal shall be suspended until the decision of such

appeal, which decision shall be final." The italics are ours. This means that the American Jewish Committee, self-constituted, has the right of veto over any matter undertaken by the New York Kehilla, there being no definition of what is local and what is national. If the American Jewish Committee were a representative committee, there would be no quarrel with this provision, we admit, but it can, or should, have no standing in the presence of an organization formed by duly elected delegates of Jewish organizations of New York. And even if the sanction of the American Jewish Committee were needed as a tactical necessity, we believe the New York Kehilla should have first exhausted its influence in securing the endorsement of hundreds of other Jewish organizations, before it approached the American Jewish Committee.

A CANDID ENEMY.

The American Israelite maintains its traditions with remarkable consistency. A few weeks ago it "contradicted a statement published in a contemporary to the effect that Hebrew was being taught in (Palestine to little children in kindergartens and schools for use as a vernacular." Dr. Martin A. Meyer, who is not a Zionist, but who has lived in Palestine as a student, sent a letter to the Israelite corroborating its contemporary. Dr. Meyer said, in part:

"I believe that my experience in Palestine puts me in a position to speak with a show of authority on such a matter as the one referred to in this clipping. I think you are misinformed if you have been lead to claim that Hebrew education is not so carried on in Palestine. In the several years that have elapsed since my sojourn in the land, I have been informed from the most reliable sources that the facilities for such educational activities have been increased. Not the least of the things which impressed me during the time I spent there was this