The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 1 · January 1909
31printed page
scan 31 of 50
THE MACCABAEAN
31

zation is "a reflex of the self-defence league started among the Jews of Russia some years ago." The Jewish Defence. League wanted to provide the Jews of Russia with arms to defend themselves against the attacks of hooligans. The New York organization aims to protect the Jews against the attacks of just such men like Dr. Philipson, who, by eliminating from Jewish life every thing but a pallid monotheism, and those instincts of charity and philanthropy that are universal, are removing the inner defences of he Jewish people. We allude elsewhere to Dr. Harris's absurd and un-Jewish excommunication of all Jews who have been smuggled into the Jewish fold "without the certificate of beleif or pracice." while he himself has denuded Jewish faith and Jewish practice to unitarian christian values. They are the foes we must guard against.

Dr. Philipson does not beleive that the rights of Jews are being invaded or impaired in this country. But as long as there are Jewish rights being impaired anywhere on God's footstool, Jews, who may not be Jews by faith or practice, may yet be permitted by assimilationists to organize to defend those rights and to prevent their further impairment. We beleive Dr. Philipson is a member of the American Jewish Committee. How many of that Committee are Jews in any other way but by race or nationality, yet we have not heard the voice of Dr. Philipson in opposition to that influential body. And we are not so cocksure about the absence of invasion of Jewish rights in this free country, which Dr. Philipson with the frenzy of a strange anxiety, so persistently claims as his own. In a democracy, the invasion of rights is a super-national phenomenon, and we need not take the trouble to point out the many evidences of this phenomenon in this country. Of the larger issues, there are the immigration restriction movement, the movement for the introduction of sectarian religion in the public school, the insistence, in so

many states, upon a strict observance of Sundey, etc.

The trouble with Dr. Philipson is that he is not an American. That is evident from his constant appeals to Americanism, as if he were afraid that his next-door neighbor doubted his assertion; from his blindness to the facts of American life, which he does not see because he is used to thinking as an emancipated Jew; from his fear that of all the nationalities in America, the Jews should not be asserting those rights in defence of which about a dozen of nationalities in America are constantly engaged.

In conclusion, the reverend compiler of Jewish apologetics may be asked, what makes him think that because the American Jewish Committee has decided to take a hand in the organization of the New York community, that the organization “will be so steered that the disquieting symptoms attending its birth hour will disappear?” While the American Jewish Committee has not been organized with due regard for the rights of the Jewish masses, in principle it stands on the same ground as does the new organization. The American Jewish Committee applies no religious or charity test to its membership; it includes non-beleivers, reform Jews, orthodox Jews, Zionists, territorialists, and Jews like Judge Mayer Sulzbeger, who are a composite of all these. In other words, it is in principle neither religious nor charitable; therefore it must be national. We fear that Dr. Philipson has overlooked the American Jewish Committee in his note of warning whcih appeared, as our readers might have surmised, in the American Israelite, whose social items represent in extenso its ideal of Jewish life.

DR. HARRIS EXCOMMUNICATES.

Dr. M. H. Harris, of New York, has publicly invited all Jews who do not possess the Jewish faith, or practice Judaism, to get out of the fold. If he