The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 1 · January 1909
19printed page
scan 19 of 50
THE MACCABAEAN
19

foundations of our revival in this country. You cannot demand work forcibly, and only by gentle means will you be able to acquire the monopoly of Jewish labor in Palestine. After all, Petach Tikvah provides work to hundreds of Jewish laborers as do all the colonies, and generally any Jew who can and desires to work, obtains employment in the towns and colonies. Let us work together in harmony for the employers and the employed, and for the revival of our land and people."

Mr. Dizenyoff letter was answered in the Hazwei which though anonymously appears to have been official.

The following is an extract:

“Mr. Dizenyoff’s letter has not fulfilled its object, for his words are one-sided, addressed to the Laborer’s Organization, without taking into consideration the mistakes of the second party. Let us suppose that the colonists have complaints against the Jewish laborers, are they therefore justified in endeavoring to get rid of them and engage strangers in their stead? There is not a shadow of doubt with regard to the preference of Jewish labor in the colonies. We say emphatically that Jewish workers have the right to earn their livelihood in the Jewish settlements.

“Though every Jew is in duty bound to provide labor for his brother, let not the colonists forget that they themselves exist by means of the Jewish commune who render them constant service. Let not any colonist exclaim, 'I am on my own land. I 'live on my land and by my own labor, and care not for communal rights, and no one therefore shoud venture to ask, What are you doing?' Let not such illogical remarks be made. No one doubts the private possessions of the colonists, but still they cannot ignore the opinion of the Jewish people to whom they appeal in times of distress.

"There are special advantages for the laborers in the colonies, and the Jew-

ish public can always demand that preference should be shown to Jewish laborers without discussing their faults. Justice offers them the birthright priv-ilage in every colony.

"And we now ask 'What have the colonists done to aid the laborers in every colony?

“Have their councils ever attempted to erect shelters and lodging houses for them? How is it that in the smallest Jewish village in Russia whose inhabitants are not so happily disposed as they, who have no support from a Baron, Ica or National Fund, finds means for assisting one another in times of trouble. Every townlet has its shelter,—but Petach Tikvah cares only for its own self. Thanks to God who moved the Odessa Committee to build the settlement of Ein Ganim near Petach Tikvah for thirty Jewish laborers, wherein to find repose and comfort. Why has not the Petach Tikvah committee considered the necessity of providing small plots of nineteen dounams of land for the laborers, and to give them possibilities to erect cottages? Why should not respectable accommodation be provided by the Petach Tikvah committee to present laborers who roll about in their stables and sheds? Let it be known that on this labor question depends the existence of the whole Jewish settlement here. The schools and the Gymnasium are attended by the chil-. dren of the colonists who will not follow the vocation of agriculturists. They would rather learn how to pay interest and live a luxurious life. There are hardly any young colonists in the country try now. Therefore, in order to strengthen the roots of civilization in this country we must try to augment the number of Jewish laborers in all the colonies, and the colonists and their representatives should be the first to give them a helping hand and to render them every facility for settling among them.”