The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 1 · January 1909
18printed page
scan 18 of 50

"In vain! Our last hopes are being trodden under foot. For its own private advantages the colony in question desired to increase the settlement of strangers with a view of wresting from us the possibility of creating in our native country—a fatherland."

This article called forth a spirited reply from Mr. Dizenyoff which may be styled "official—" Mr. Dizenyoff being one of the best Zionists in the country, and occupying a representative position. He entered the controversy as neither colonist nor laborer, but as one who had a right to speak on the general aspect of the question. "You are waging war with the old and new settlement, as if you alone survive to be true to the banner of life, unbelieving as you do that no one except the laborers are seriously thinking of the development of Palestine."

"Do you really believe," asks Mr.Dizenyoff, "that the colonies and theNational Institutions are so corrupted asto oppose the progress of Jewish labor? If so, you should give up all yourendeavors. Why should you deceiveyourselves? Could you provide PetachTikvah with Jewish instead of Arab laborers? Could you find all the grooms,coachmen and watchmen required by thesaid colony? What we want is naturalworkmen and not artificial, such as theimmigration affords, workmen who canget accustomed to the simple mode oflife of the Arab laborers. And if thereare colonists who are antagonistic tothe Jewish laborers for well-knownreasons, is it then your obligation toincrease the opposition and kindle theflames of hatred in the hearts ofbrothers who generally toil in the samefield? Do you really and honestly thinkthat you can forcibly demand the confidence of the colonists in the laborers?"

"At first we were all pleased to see a laborer's union which carried on business in the proper way, freed from socialistic squabbles. We were glad to

know that we had as yet no exploiters and no capitalists, and that our duty was therefore to strengthen the hands of the colonists and business-men, and to ameliorate the burdens of the laborers. We thought that your organization would call here the natural laborers who understand and wish to work, and remove from our midst those who cannot or will not work. We hoped that you would arrange for lessons in agriculture and farming, create mutual loan and savings funds for your members and care for the sick and disabled.

But instead of the noble work of building up an organization, you are engaged in destructive work. You are quarreling and slandering everyone of the settlement by calling every idealist a traitor to his people. The results have been disastrous to you, for the more refined characters of your organization have severed every connection with you. Can you force upon us the useless element of the laborers? By such means you are but sowing the seeds of emnity between farmer and laborer, and encouraging the latter to prefer the field of strife to the field of plenty. By introducing the principles of compulsory work, you are only enfeebling the cause of union. Work must be guided by economic laws that cannot be disregarded. Laborers who do not understand their work, or who stake the properties of the colonists as the watchmen in Rechoboth did, or who proclaim that Stein's Foundry is their own, cannot be encouraged to work in the colonies. I have not entered the arena of polemics to reproach the laborers or to defend the Girl's School or Stein's factory. I have done so because it grieves me to think that the element which proposed building have chosen another course. We have already enough dissension among us, and can therefore do without more. I appeal to you to recede from your false ways. Teach your members to love their work, and to build, the