councils. Possibly, also, some new division of the country for administrative purposes, and more in accord with the ethnic frontiers, will be necessary, a demand which has already come from Macedonia.
"That this principle will be an equitable one I have no doubt, for the Young Turks are too well versed in modern politics to repeat the mistake made by Germany in its treatment of the Poles or of England in its dealings with the Irish. In fact, the Young Turks may teach Europe a second lesson no less momentous than the first—that a state is far better served when it allows the widest range to the national and racial aspirations of its coherent parts than when its seeks to stifle these aspirations and produces sores which fester for all time to come."
SCHULMAN ON ZANGWILL AND INTERMARRIAGE.
—DR. S. SCHULMAN, rabbi of Temple Beth-El of New York, a rabbi anti-Zionist and a doughty champion of the Jewish mission in exile, has preached a sermon on "Intermarriage" full of malicious and ill-natured criticism of Israel Zangwill, which the American Hebrew reproduces in extenso. Incidentally, Dr. Schulman claims credit for the invention of the term "melting-pot," and quotes chapter and verse to prove it. He believes that we Jews should assimilate to our environment as much as possible, without surrendering the essential principles of our faith. "We are to emphasize the prophetic element of our religion." It is just this point of view which Zangwill presents when he speaks of the "melting-pot" influence of America. If the Jewish religion is merely a prophetic religion, then the barrier that divides Jew and Gentile is removed, and there is nothing in religion or ethics against intermarriage. Does Dr. Schulman fear that in the intermingling of Jew and Gentile the prophetic religion will be lost? Yes. Then what shall
preserve the Jew as Jew? is the question Zangwill asks. The religion of Dr. Schulman is not strong enough to do it. Christianity is an extension of the prophetic religion Dr. Schulman expounds. Christianity is actually the prophetic religion. It had its legitimate inception in the breaking away from the national limits. There is no principle in Dr. Schulman's version of prophetic Judaism which safeguards its existence as the basis of a church. The logical conclusion is the "melting-pot."
THE JEWISH PUBLICATION SOCIETY AND PAVONDA.
—Toe Jewish Publication Society has refused the offer of a writer whose nom de plume is Halitvack, to publish a volume of his stories of Pavonda life. This in itself does not warrant notice, for the Publication Society has greatly stimulated Jewsh liter-' ature in this country before by refusing to publish the works of Jewish writers. Nor is the introduction of Pavonda into public notice of any consequence, for who of us really knows where Pavonda is? Mr. Halitvack, however, has made himself famous by protesting against the edict of the Society. He believes, with the simplicity and modesty of a true artist, that his Pavonda sketches are “unique in their trend and finished with the technique of the finished craftsman.” Then he asks, venting his just indignation aganst the members of the Society, “can you offer in answer to this injustice to yourselves and this insane and damnable discouragement of talent, which you are called upon to vindicate?” He becomes quite plaintive and embarrasses the poor members of the Society further: “Would you expect me to continue to write Jewish stories, to produce Jewish literature after you, the Jewish Publication Society, have shut your door with a bang in one’s face?” Perhaps that is why the Publication Committee returned his manuscript after holding it for four months.
