of a narrower field of competitors, the workmen in their employ are not secure from the competition of workmen coming into this country. The longer this partial protection is in force, the more imperative becomes the need, from the workman's point of view, of the restriction of immigration. The workmen become keen to the fact that, while the manufacturer enjoys the favor of limited competition, they are open to continual disturbance of their wage standard by the influx of foreign labor.
The growth of restriction sentiment in America may be traced back to the introduction of the protective system. While the restrictionists may base their arguments against the aliens on various grounds, while they may conjure up all sorts of dangers based on prejudices, in essence, the popular feeling against immigration has its roots in a disinclination to have the labor field invaded by large groups of alien workmen.
It is therefore reasonable to hope, that as the protective theory weakens in this country, immigration restriction will also lose its hold on the masses. This presupposes, of course, that the tariff revision now being considered will be in the direction of reduction, and not of increases in the schedule.
It is possible, however, that before much can be done to reduce the tariff, the restrictionists may have won their fight.
A WEAK CHAMPION OF ORTHODOXY.
THE Amerian Hebrew has raised the question of the existence of reform judaism in a manner which is far from illuminating. It will be agreed by orthodox as well as reform Jews that the American Hebrew has not raised the issue as one might have expected from an organ of so-called conservative Judaism. It assumed reform Judaism to be a sincere religious phenomenon, and then proceeded to raise a question in a manner not unlike the question now being discussed among politicians, whether the democratic party shall abandon radical theories, and go back to the good old doctrine of tariff reform and state-rights. In other words, the American Hebrew con-
siders religion a matter of convenience, adjustment, compromise, opportunism.
All this confirms the criticism of Zionism of all religious manifestations among the Jews: it is utterly impossible to disentangle the confusion which arises owing to the distinction that must be raised, by every sincere person, between the religion of the individual, and the religion of a national group, which still has national problems to rid itself of. The American Hebrew is probably no more orthodox than reform rabbis are, but in order to conserve certain interests of Jewish solidarity, it smothers all its religious feelings and takes up religion as one of the means of perpetuating the Jewish race. The Jewish nation cannot, however, be maintained in the religious form. It must re-establish itself on its own territory, re-assume its normal national life, before it can be freed from the delusions of compromise, “catholic Judaism,” and the like.
Dr. STEPHEN S. Wise, formerly quite an enthusiastie Zionist, has become the sensation of New York by publicly attacking those Supreme Court Judges, who as- ssisted in a social dinner given to Richard Croker, former Tammany chief.and now retired "worker for his own pocket all the time.” - Dr. Wise pointed out that the conduet of the judges in countenancing the return to this country of a man who had outraged the city in the past is deserving of the censure of all good citizens. Without entering into the merits of the questıon at ıssue, however, it is a pity that Dr. Wise does not use his talents in the interests of Zionism, more than he has done since he has taken up with the Free Synagogue. Does the Free Synagogue muzzle its preacher on Zionism ?
Tre article on the Situation in Turkey, by Dr. Isaac A. Hourwich, which appeared in the last issue of Tue MAcCAaBAEAN, was taken from the Jewish Zukunft, edited by Dr. C. Wortsmann. A number of paragraphs enlarging the article as it appeared in the Zukunft, had been promised, but at che last moment they were not fortheoming. The artiele consequently appeared as it was printed in the Zukunft, without any amendments or alterations by Dr. Hourwich.