The Maccabaean · Vol. XV, No. 6 · December 1908
252printed page
scan 30 of 54
252
THE MACCABAEAN

THE MACCABAEAN

Published once every month by The Maccabean Publishing Company. M. B. Lande, President; D. H. Lieberman, Treasurer; address for the business of the corporation, 547 Broadway, N. Y.

DECEMBER, 1908.

THE PRESENT STATUS OF THE ITO.

It is reported, on good authority, that the geographical commission sent out by the Ito organization has found the territory investigated, at present unknown, unfavorable for colonization purposes, and therefore useless as a haven of refuge for the Jewish people.

This places the Ito organization in a position of great delicacy. All the ingenuity of Zangwill and his co-workers will be required to meet the complaints of their followers. For the first time in the history of this offshoot of Zionism, it will have to meet objections that cannot be met by reference to the possibilities in store for the Jewish people via the Ito. The period of gestation is over. The Ito is expected to produce something. A continuous performance of investigation is not possible. Even if the Ito had secured a territory, its position was bound to be impaired by the selection of any territory, for that territory would have had to compare favorably with Palestine. Now, however, with an adverse report, which means that the Ito is in the same place it was three years ago, the base of the organization so devo- tedly led by Israel Zangwill falls to the ground and disappears.

What Zangwill will do now, of course, no one can prophesy. That he has within the past few months been more kindly disposed toward Zionism, is evidenced in the article or interview he contributed to the Independent recently, in which he spoke throughout as a Zionist. The effects of the Ito organization will not go to waste, we believe. The Ito has, in many ways, made nationalism more palatable to a number of influential persons. It remains to be seen,

in case the affairs of the Ito are placed in the hands of a receiver, whether there will be anything tangible to turn over to Zionism, which is, as it were, the only visible legatee of the decendent.

DR. LEWIN'S SECOND AMERICAN TOUR.

DR. S. LEWIN comes to us this year not as a Zionist agitator, but specifically in the interests of education in Palestine. He intends to appeal for funds to those Jews who, while they may not favor the Basile program, at least feel sufficiently in sympathy with the idea of reviving Palestine as an educational center, to give of their means to establish educational institutions.

Dr. Lewin does well not to work in both camps at the same time. It is not the special duty of the Zionist propagandist to collect funds for an institution which has already the support of a powerful Jewish organization in Germany, and a large donation from the Wizzotsky family. Dr. Lewin takes up that work in his private capacity, and what he does ın his private capacity, which at least is of value to Pales- time, also deserves encouragement.

We Zionists must appreciate the importance of maintaining the integrity of our position. Philanthropy, in Palestine, is good; we laud those who give for Palestine needs, but to devote ourselves to the labor of securing financial aid for any but national institutions in Palestine, will mean the abandonment of the Zionism of to-day and the return to Chovevi Zionism.

Dr. Lewin, we know, understands that Zionism must act astheinspirer of all activities having Palestine as their goal. We do not plant colonies; we inspire Zionists, or Tews, to do that. We do not maintaın the Bezalel school; Zionists and lovers of Jewish art do that. Nor do we propose supporting the technical school in Haifa; we leave that work to the workers who feel specially interested in that school. The Zionist organization must act as the representative of Jewish interests, in a political sense, universally, and in Palestine. Every thing of direct, positive value in