the cultivators limit their production for fear of reducing the prices, and it is here where the Régie comes into direct competition with the exporters, but in all other districts, by the terms of its convention, the Régie must purchase all the tobacco grown. It naturally follows that much inferior tobacco is produced, which is useless for purposes of export and which the Régie is obliged to utilize. In six years the present concession comes to an end.”
THE BINGHAM AFFAIR IN NEW YORK.
In the early part of the month, Police Commissioner Bingham, of New York, published an article in the North American Re- vicw, in which, in the course of an argument favoring a special secret police for the detection of crime among the various foreign nationalities in New York, he asserted that probably fifty per cent. of the foreign criminals in the city were of Jewish parentage. This was not the first statement made by the ‚Mr. Bingham which reflected discredit upon the Jewish people. _A few months ago he asserted that. over a majority of the criminals pictured in the Rogues’ Gallery were Jewish. The statement in the North American Re- wiew, however, aroused the indignation of the ‚East Side to such an extent that mass-meetings were held, editorials were written, statistics were published, and Mr. Bingham was clearly shown to have erred in his figures, and to have done a serious injustice to the Jews of New York. Letters appeared in the general press, of which Mr. Schiff’s presented the matter in the best spirit and manner. Mr. Schiff wrote:
“I have always had much respect for the commissioner because of the efficient manner in which he conducts his department, and am therefore the more at loss to understand how he can justify the giving out of figures which certainly have been based only upon superficial observation and without any investigation of the facts.
"The latter have been only recently thoroughly inquired into by Mr. M. A. Katz, who at the instance of a number of citizens of the Jewish faith has prepared an elaborate table of statistics which is at Commissioner Bingham's disposal. These statistics prove that Jews are seldom convicted of serious crimes and that the percentage of minor offenses on the part of Jews is far below their proportion of the population.
"What is Commissioner Bingham driving at? Does he wish to add to the unfortunate
prejudice which already exists against the foreigner in general and the Jew in particular and is he in favor of restricting immigration, illegitimately using his official position to further his ends?
"Of the large influx from foreign countries of which so considerable a part has remained in New York City, only those who in their struggle for an existence have lost their hold and fallen are pointed out for the purpose of discrediting the foreigner. The enormous number of newcomers who have been absorbed in the general population and who through honest toil by day and night have helped perhaps more than the native born to make a great metropolis of New York and build up its commercial supremacy, is passed unnoticed. It is among this silent multitude that the Jew will be found to be leading."
‚ The position taken by the Yiddish press was uniform in its strong condemnation of rash statements tending to create räce prejudice, but the American Hebrew, the leading Jewish paper in English here, took a most curious position in the matter. It first rebuked 'Mr. Bingham, and disputed his figures, but the following week it declared that the outery of the East Side, and of prominent Jews, as to the gravity of the charges, should be attributed to “Jewish Sensitiveness,” for, it asserted, Mr. Bingham had not intended his paper as a contribution to statistical knowledge, but rather for the improvement of his department, and he had not given figures, .but merely his impression. The American Hebrew thus missed the point. It did not see that, if Mr. Bingham had actually given figures, there might have been an excuse for him, but dealing only in impressions, he was all the more culpable for circulating a notion so harmful to the Jews, and so unwarranted by the facts.
THE BINGHAM RETRACTION.
MR. BINGHAM has since made a complete retraction. He declares that his figures were untrue and misleading. He disavows any prejudice against the Jews, and regrets his error. This retraction has been received in some quaters with great satisfaction; in others, it is not so satisfying. It should not be satisfactory to those who believe that the creation of race prejudice is a mighty serious matter, and that in a public official such carelessness and gross negligence cannot be