The Maccabaean · Vol. XV, No. 3 · September 1908
140printed page
scan 34 of 44
Facsimile · scan 34 of 44
Scan of p. 140
Text · transcribed from the scan

representative organizations. They are not responsible to any constituency. They have no constituency, but all their work is made possible and has its origin, not in any special ability their leaders display, but because they have the use of millions, which were left by a great philanthropist for the solution of Jewish problems. The American Jewish Committee is an instrument of a party of worthy gentlemen, who disdain to be accountable to the Jewish people for what they do; they conduct their sessions in secrecy, refuse to admit the Jewish press, and make no public statement of their income and disbursements.

When the Zionist organization sent out a call for a conference to discuss Jewish affairs, not one of the organizations in the coalition deigned to attend a conference where accountability to the Jewish people was a part of the constitution of the party calling it. If their interests were the interests of the Jewish people, why should they have refused to send delegates? Because once they admit the principle of democracy into their work, their autocratic power is at an end, or, at least, their unchecked whims and prejudices would have to give way to the power of public opinion.

Should the Zionist organization now be invited to join the coalition, for special purposes, we hope that it will refuse. Not out of pique, but because the best interests of the Jewish people demand that the issue of democracy in Jewish life shall be fought out in the open. Jewish self-consciousness will never be awakened by a set of benevolent philanthropists ; in this case, using the bequest of a defunct philanthropist as if it were their own; Jewish self-consciousness and self-emancipation will come only through the recognition of the principles of democracy in Jewish life.

ZIONISTS STICK TO THEIR LAST.

SHOULD the Ito, in its search for a territory, find what it is looking for in the course of a few months, we shall cry out, in all sincerity, "Good luck to the Ito," and there will be good cause for offering Mr. Zangwill, and, for

that matter, the entire Jewish people, our congratulations. The Ito has been in the position of the man who had no home, but hoped to have one some day, and who was always saying, that the home he expected to get was better than the one another man had made up his mind to possess. There was no contradicting him.

When his meraglim have returned, and presented as a report, probably Mr. Zangwill will not ask for a geological, topographical, hydraulic, industrial and political investigation before he lays the matter before his geographical commission. He may be content with a free territory, in a good location, with undeveloped resources, which will remain to be explored. Nor will he, we surmise, find smooth sailing for his idea of autonomy, for there are quite a few of the men in his immediate counsels, who will not agree to the principle of autonomy, men who have not developed very far away from the Goluth type of Marrano.

But, whatever the difficulties in the way of the Ito, we are sure that all Zionists will agree that, excluding it as a disciple of Zionism and classing it as a movement to preserve the status quo in more tolerable from, and in spite of the fact that its success might mean a temporary set-back to Zionism, the Ito deserves our sympathy, for it has at least the self-sacrifice of Israel Zangwill, his imagination and his rhetorical power, as well as his inherent love of the Jewish people, to commend it.

Zionists, however, will stick to their last. They will work and wait, and will not be moved from their aim, which is, was, and ever shall be, the acquisition of a legally and publicly assured home for the Jewish people in Palestine.. The Ito may find Texas or Abyssinia, North or East Africa, but Palestine will one day find the Jewish people, and then the problems of the Itoists, as well as the Zionists, will be taken out of their hands, and will be settled by the Jewish people living on their own soil.