The Maccabaean · Vol. XV, No. 3 · September 1908
137printed page
scan 31 of 44
Facsimile · scan 31 of 44
Scan of p. 137
Text · transcribed from the scan

agitation known as Zionism. To our mind, it seems to have no other purpose than creating in the Jew a sense of alienation, and making prejudice deeper in the non-Jew.'

"It may all be due to my lack of understanding, but I am utterly astonished at the mere thought of an eminent exponent of Judaism thus calling into doubt the patriotism of a large element of his fellow-Jews, because of their devotion to an idea, which according to their best light, stands for the welfare of our people. It passeth, at least, my understanding that a rabbi will thus disparage the citizenship of a large part of the Jews in America, for their devotion to the whole Jewish nationality, when, as a matter of common history, past and present, the representatives here of the various peoples of the Old World have ever taken a keen interest in the struggles and achievements of their respective nationalities. No one has ever dared to disparage the patriotism of the representatives of any one of these peoples, because of their interest in the fate of their separate nationality, and so far as it is known, there has never come anyone out of the midst of these peoples to call his brethren unpatriotic. I have before me, together with the statement of Dr. Krauskopf, expressions of many eminent non-Jewish Americans, who have not only approved of the interest which Jews in this country have taken in Zionism, but who have admired the loyalty to our race and religion which has promoted these activities in behalf of the whole of Israel, the greatest part of which is living in a state of persecution, oppression and utter hopelessness, in so far as the future is concerned. There are those different opinions before me, and in the presence of the solemn edict of a noted Jewish divine, I am confused as to what is the right and the wrong of the matter.

"Only the other day, the Rev. Dr. Edward Everett Hale wrote to the Zionists of Boston telling them of his sympathy with the Zionist movement, and expressing his ardent hope for the establishment of a political home in Palestine for the great masses of our people who now dwell in darkness and misery. He would spur the Zionists on to further activi-

ties, and he suggests the creation of a special line of steamships that would carry our persecuted brothren direct from Russia to the East, to the land of our fathers. And I want to know whether the author of 'The Man Without a Country' is urging us on to treason. Another matter that adds to my confusion is the fact that all Zionists with whom I have ever come in contact are strongly attached to this country, and that so many of the Jewish young men who fought for our flag in the recent war with Spain, came out of the immigrant elements, which largely belong to the orthodox school of Judaism, and a great part of which is imbued with the ideal of Zionism. Dr. Krauskopf offers considerable advice to the orthodox Jews, but in view of the spiritual chaos and emptiness that prevails in the camps of Jewish Reform, and in view of the real fervor and ardent devotion to old-time ideals that permeates so much of the life of the newly arrived and orthodox, or at least, conservative Jews, I am again rather uncertain as to the side on which wisdom resides.

"In one part of his speech, Dr. Krauskopf takes us to task for our exclusiveness, for excluding Gentiles from our societies, etc., and in another part of the speech he tells us of the discriminations and outrages to which we Jews are subjected. Does he believe that the social gulf can be bridged by opening our doors wide to those who hate us? Will our detractors come and give us their love merely upon our invitation? It may all be the fault of the reporter and it may be that if the latter part of the speech was placed before the first, it would all have been clearer to me, but as it is I fail to follow the drift of the argument, and I humbly beg for enlightenment. Dr. Krauskopf says that Zionism will tend to create prejudice against us. I have always thought that prejudice against us has existed long before Zionism was promulgated. Am I wrong? I should be thankful to the reverend doctor for setting me right on any one of the points, on which I am seeking a better understanding of his views."